Read the Gemini Evaluation of US Coin Shows
🏪

Security Rare Coins

ID: 3357 Store 354 mi from you Lancaster, PA 17601 +1 (717) 291-9621
4.5 (119 reviews)
Share this Dealer

About Security Rare Coins

Lancaster's trusted coin dealer since 1979, Security Rare Coins specializes in buying and selling rare coins, gold, silver, and precious metals with a commitment to fair pricing and honest dealings. As Lancaster County's leading numismatics expert, they pay up to 40% more for gold and offer competitive prices on coins, paper money, jewelry, estates, and antiques with knowledgeable service and convenient transactions. Get your best offer today from a community-trusted dealer dedicated to treating customers with respect and integrity.

Imported Listing Last verified: February 26, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review
4.5
★★★★½
9 reviews · 4.5 (110 on Google)
5
9
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
0
Lisa Sauter
Lisa Sauter Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Great Place! Maggie & Jeff are wonderful to deal with! Referred lots of folks to them...and continue to be their customer on going...been going there for years...since the 70's when the previous family member was running the business for various things... highly recommend! 💞💯

Heather
Heather Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Me & my sons first time here and what we experienced exceeded our expectations. The costumer service, knowledgeability, & attention to detail were second to none despite being there during a busy time. Will definitely be back.

Renee Showvaker
Renee Showvaker Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

I just started collecting coins two months ago…Jeff treats his customers like royalty whether you’re spending $3 or $3,000…even with a line out the door, Jeff is willing to take the time to make you feel like you’re the most important person in the room! No one better in the business…fair, honest, and knowledgeable!

Lisa J
Lisa J Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

highly recommend going here. owners were extremely helful and knowledgeable. very fair.

Carl Gorman (Hedgehog)
Carl Gorman (Hedgehog) Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Outstanding coin shop have been in about 10 times bought and sold about 1,000 worth of coins and metals. Prices are well below online for any coin. Pays really well for gold and silver jewelry for example had .80 sterling silver vintage rattle other shop in town offered $5 here I was paid far more fair at 15. Have witnessed about 25 people sell to owner while in shop always seen great prices. Great place to buy and sell very informative honest Jeff the owner and wife. Safe, clean and good lighting. Amazing coin selection! Get a quote for your item from Jeff the owner then go to the 3 other places in central PA area and I guarantee you’ll be back to see Jeff for more Money and more respect. UPDATE : Late July 2025 Went in today with my son whose name I said twice. Was very impressed that Jeff remembered his name after we’ve been in there for about 35 minutes. Prices for gold were STILL! The lowest then any online store I could find in the amount of gold I was looking for I did not know that security coin does estate appraisal. For coins and I’m assuming precious metals. Amazing being a coin collector with a few kids. The shop will go through them an estimate on the value of the collection as well as can itemize them so if you’re setting an estate. I did not ask about the price of service (i’ll be dead so i’m not worried about it) Lucky to have a local shop that’s More Affordable and has the knowledge and experience to answer questions as long as they’re open. Shopping local is great this guys pays taxes and lives here, STILL THE LOWST PRICE, no minimums for free shipping!

View on Google
Brandon S
Brandon S Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

First time in a coin shop and I do believe I found a good one! Very personable and educated with fair pricing! Sold some 14k gold jewelry and they seem to pay out higher then what the general percentage is for coin shops/precision metal buyers. I would recommend my elderly grandmother to go in alone and be given the same honest fair treatment! Ill be back! Thanks again!

View on Google
T.C.
T.C. Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

It was my first time stopping by this shop this past Saturday, and I’m so glad I did! Jeff is a great guy, and is very knowledgeable in what he does. His selection was impressive and well extensive (especially with the growing demand of precious metals this year!). Finding these types of small businesses is rare nowadays! 100% would recommend if anyone is interested in stopping by. I’m definitely going to be stopping by again! Thank you Jeff! Happy stacking! 🏅🪙

View on Google
Andrew Lehman
Andrew Lehman Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

I love this place! Jeff (owner) has been super helpful and has been teaching me a ton about coins and bullion. He is a huge asset to me during my precious metals stacking journey. His prices are great and he is very honest. We are lucky to have this store in our town. I will be a customer for life. Go check out the store!

View on Google
A B
A B Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Jeff makes me very happy 2-3 times a week. i tell him i’ll see him next week but come back next day. His shop is the best around. I am grateful of this kind heartwarming family business. He’s kind to me and my whole family. My kids love stopping in, he gives them a kind hearted smile, and a chocolate coin and sticker each time! This is my favorite coin shop in all the ones i’ve been to. Can’t wait to wake up and walk on into his shop! Thanks Jeff, wife and family for all you do!!!!!

View on Google

Write a Review

You must be logged in to leave a review.

Log In to Review