This Toronto coin dealer specializes in buying and selling coins, stamps, and numismatic collectibles for both seasoned collectors and newcomers. Bay Coins & Stamps offers expert appraisals and a curated selection of rare coins and precious metals in the heart of Toronto, ON. Whether you're looking to build your collection or sell valuable pieces, this established shop provides professional service and fair market pricing.
This Toronto coin dealer specializes in buying and selling coins, stamps, and numismatic collectibles for both seasoned collectors and newcomers. Bay Coins & Stamps offers expert appraisals and a curated selection of rare coins and precious metals in the heart of Toronto, ON. Whether you're looking to build your collection or sell valuable pieces, this established shop provides professional service and fair market pricing.
Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.
0
The gentleman who served me was very kind! Greetings from Spain— Franxu Baz, Jan 2026
5 star review— Shanalika Naraine, Feb 2026
Great store and even better owner. The man is an absolute delight and helps in anyway he can His knowledge of coins and currency is impeccable and he is always happy and friendly. Highly recommend this spot for all your coin needs!!!— Jatique Khan, Jan 2025
I would like too say that Mr. Peter was a pleasure too do business with. Mr. Peter has so much knowledge regarding Coins and Stamps. Also he's a very fair man. I was pleasantly surprised with the amount that I got for my Coins. Thank you Mr. Peter for all your help. Yours truly, Ana Rodrigues— Ana Rodrigues, May 2025
Peter has been a reliable, direct and honest coin dealer for the 15 years that I have been dealing with him. While not a boutique store it also doesn't have boutique prices but you still get his years of experience. His prices are always the best of any accessible coin store in Toronto.— Andrei Bucur, Apr 2025
Went for a ".50 cent coin "and was treated like a queen ! They have to be the nicest,kindest and generous owners. Wonderful service!— Ahick Cman, Dec 2025
Overpriced with a hint of greed. Even the spiking silver prices are not enough for them to sell at (an increased) spot, they add premiums. This is not an issue with rare coins, but with modern ones that cost way less than today’s spot price is a bit controversial. I did not buy anything at all, however, I wanted to pick up 3-4 world coins as well. Won’t be back and won’t suggest to fellow collectors. Dealers at coin shows work with better prices and customer service.— Attila Árvai, Jan 2026
You must be logged in to leave a review.
Log In to Review
