Skip to content

Coin Dealers in New York

New York is home to a network of independent coin dealers and gold buyers, concentrated around New York City, White Plains and Suffern. Beyond show weekends, these dealers offer year-round buying, selling, and appraisal services — a place to sell an inherited collection, get bullion weighed, or have a rare find authenticated without waiting for the next show. Local shops frequently overlap with the American Numismatic Society (ANS) club network, so a dealer visit and a show trip often lead to the same people.

Claim Your Profile
Advertisement

Numismatic Associations in New York

+116 more cities
CommackCopake FallsCoramDeer ParkDepewEast IslipEast MeadowEast SyracuseElmhurstElmira HeightsElmsfordEndicottErie CountyFarmingvilleFayettevilleFredoniaFreeportGarden CityGenevaGlens FallsGreene CountyHalesiteHarrisonHartsdaleHastings On HudsonHauppaugeHicksvilleHolbrookHopewell JunctionHuntingtonIslipIthacaJamestownJohnson CityKanonaKenmoreKingstonLake GroveLake RonkonkomaLancasterLewistonLindenhurstLiverpoolLong Island CityLynbrookMahopacMassapequaMassapequa ParkMelvilleMerrickMiddle IslandMiddletownMonseyMount KiscoMount VernonNanuetNew HartfordNew RochelleNew YorkNewburghNorth BabylonNorth Bay ShoreNorth SyracuseNyackOakdaleOrange CountyOwegoOxfordPalmyraPatchoguePenfieldPhoeniciaPlainviewPlandomePlattsburghPort JeffersonPoughkeepsieQueensRensselaerRidgewoodRiverheadRochesterRockville CentreRocky PointRomeRonkonkomaSackets HarborSaint JamesSaratoga SpringsSayvilleScarsdaleSeldenShortsvilleSide Door HamburgSlingerlandsSpring ValleyStaten IslandSyracuseThe BronxTonawandaUticaVictorWading RiverWatkins GlenWebsterWest BabylonWestburyWhite PlainsWilliamsonWilliamsvilleWilmingtonWoodburyWoodmereYonkersYorkYorktown Heights
C

Carl Burnstein Coins and Autographs

Verified

New York, NY

5.0(4)

This New York, NY coin dealer specializes in rare coins, numismatics, and autographed memorabilia for collectors and investors. Carl Burnstein Coins and…

C

Cash For Gold

Verified

Auburn, NY

4.7(23)

This Auburn, NY coin dealer specializes in buying and selling coins and precious metals to collectors and investors alike. With expertise in numismatics, they…

C

Cashdealgoldbuyers

Verified

New York, NY

4.8(26)

Cash Deal Gold Buyers is a leading coin dealer in New York, NY specializing in buying and selling gold and silver coins with guaranteed best pricing and 100%…

Cayuga Coins logo

Cayuga Coins

Verified

Ithaca, NY

Cayuga Coins is a trusted coin dealer in Ithaca, NY offering competitive pricing on precious metals including gold, silver, platinum, and palladium. Whether…

Center Gold East | Buy Sell & Pawn Gold, Silver, Diamonds logo

Center Gold East | Buy Sell & Pawn Gold, Silver, Diamonds

Verified

Rocky Point, NY

4.9(44)

Center Gold East is a locally owned coin dealer and precious metals shop serving Rocky Point and surrounding Long Island communities with over 50 years of…

Center Gold II Buy & Sell Gold, Silver, Coins & Diamonds logo

Center Gold II Buy & Sell Gold, Silver, Coins & Diamonds

Verified

Farmingville, NY

5.0(72)

With over 50 years of experience, Center Gold II is a trusted coin dealer in Farmingville, NY offering expert buying and selling of gold, silver, coins, and…

C

Center Island Jeweler | Buy Sell Diamonds/Gold/Silver/Coins

Verified

Saint James, NY

5.0(2)

Center Island Jeweler is a trusted coin dealer in Saint James, NY specializing in buying and selling coins, diamonds, gold, silver, and rare numismatic pieces.…

Central New York Coin & Silver Inc. logo

Central New York Coin & Silver Inc.

Verified

Liverpool, NY

4.3(45)

Central New York's gold standard for coin dealers, Central New York Coin & Silver Inc. in Liverpool, NY buys and sells coins, currency, bullion, and precious…

Advertisement
C

Centurial Collectibles

Verified

Coram, NY

Centurial Collectibles is a coin dealer in Coram, NY specializing in high-quality certified U.S. Paper Money and coins. We are dedicated to offering the finest…

Paper Money
C

Challenge Coin Kings

Verified

New York, NY

Challenge Coin Kings is a premier coin dealer in New York, NY specializing in custom challenge coins with superior craftsmanship and industry-leading expertise.…

Champion Stamp Co., Inc. logo

Champion Stamp Co., Inc.

Verified

New York, NY

3.9(64)

Champion Stamp Co., Inc. is a trusted coin dealer in New York, NY specializing in numismatics and rare coins for collectors and investors. With expertise in…

C

Choice Forex Inc.

Verified

New York, NY

2.0(8)

Choice Forex Inc. is a premier coin dealer in New York, NY, specializing in buying and selling coins, rare numismatics, and precious metals. With expertise in…

Christopher Young Coins logo

Christopher Young Coins

Verified

Ithaca, NY

4.8(42)

Christopher Young Coins is Ithaca's premier coin dealer and appraiser with over 40 years of experience buying, selling, and trading rare coins and precious…

C

Clarkstown Coin & Jewelry

Verified

Nanuet, NY

5.0(1,258)

Clarkstown Coin & Jewelry is a family-owned coin dealer in Nanuet, NY specializing in rare coins, precious metals, diamonds, and fine jewelry, with a team of…

C

Coin Dealer Hamburg, NY

Verified

Side Door Hamburg, NY

4.9(136)

Classic Rarities is a trusted coin dealer in Hamburg, NY specializing in buying and selling coins, rare currency, and numismatic collections with over 26 years…

C

Coin Exchange NY: Buy & Sell Coins, Gold & More

Verified

Hartsdale, NY

4.6(264)
Advertisement
Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay logo

Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay

Verified

Lynbrook, NY

4.0(29)

Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay has been a trusted coin dealer in Lynbrook, NY since 1974, offering nearly five decades of expertise in buying and selling rare…

C

Coin Masters

Verified

Buffalo, NY

4.8(15)

Coin Masters is Buffalo's premier coin dealer and top numismatics store, offering the largest selection of rare coins and collectables from around the world and…

C

Coin Wrap Inc

Verified

Albany, NY

Coin Wrap Inc is a trusted coin dealer in Albany, NY offering a comprehensive selection of coins and numismatic items for collectors of all levels. We buy and…

C

Coins and Collectibles Inc.

Verified

Avon, NY

5.0(12)

Located in Avon, NY, this established coin dealer specializes in buying and selling coins, rare numismatic pieces, and precious metals for collectors and…

C

Cold Spring Coin Curr

Verified

Cold Spring, NY

5.0(10)

Cold Spring Coin Curr is a trusted coin dealer in Cold Spring, NY, offering a wide selection of numismatic coins and precious metals for collectors and…

C

Colonial Stamp & Coin Co

Verified

Kingston, NY

4.7(65)

Colonial Stamp & Coin Co is a trusted coin dealer in Kingston, NY specializing in numismatics and rare coins for collectors and investors. We buy and sell coins…

C

Cool Ice Nyc

Verified

New York, NY

5.0(6)

COOL ICE NYC is a premier coin dealer in New York, NY specializing in coins, rare numismatics, and precious metals for collectors and investors. We buy and sell…

C

Costello's Rare Coins

Verified

Halesite, NY

5.0(15)

This Halesite, NY coin dealer specializes in rare coins and numismatic collectibles for both seasoned collectors and newcomers. Costello's Rare Coins buys and…

See New York Coin Shows →
Also browse dealers in: Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Vermont

Frequently Asked Questions

Where can I find coin dealers in New York?
There are 314 coin dealers listed in New York on US Coin Shows. Browse by city using the filters above, or search for dealers by specialty.
What do coin dealers in New York buy?
Coin dealers in New York typically buy and sell U.S. coins, world coins, paper currency, gold and silver bullion, tokens, medals, and numismatic supplies. Many also purchase estates and collections. Check individual dealer profiles for their specific specialties.
How do I sell my coins to a dealer in New York?
Find a coin dealer near you in New York using the listings above. Contact the dealer directly to arrange a meeting or bring your coins to a local coin show where multiple dealers can make offers. It's always a good idea to get multiple opinions before selling.
Are there coin shows in New York where I can meet dealers?
Yes — many coin dealers in New York attend local and regional coin shows. Visit the New York coin shows page on US Coin Shows to find upcoming events where you can meet dealers in person.
Advertisement
Advertisement