Coin Dealers in New York

New York is home to a network of independent coin dealers and gold buyers, concentrated around New York City, White Plains and Suffern. Beyond show weekends, these dealers offer year-round buying, selling, and appraisal services — a place to sell an inherited collection, get bullion weighed, or have a rare find authenticated without waiting for the next show. Local shops frequently overlap with the American Numismatic Society (ANS) club network, so a dealer visit and a show trip often lead to the same people.

Claim Your Profile

Numismatic Associations in New York

American Numismatic Society (ANS) →

Albany Alton Amenia Arlington Athens Auburn Avon Babylon Bellmore Bethpage Big Indian Bohemia Bronxville Brooklyn Buffalo Canandaigua Carmel Hamlet Centereach Cheektowaga Cold Spring

+116 more cities

Commack Copake Falls Coram Deer Park Depew East Islip East Meadow East Syracuse Elmhurst Elmira Heights Elmsford Endicott Erie County Farmingville Fayetteville Fredonia Freeport Garden City Geneva Glens Falls Greene County Halesite Harrison Hartsdale Hastings On Hudson Hauppauge Hicksville Holbrook Hopewell Junction Huntington Islip Ithaca Jamestown Johnson City Kanona Kenmore Kingston Lake Grove Lake Ronkonkoma Lancaster Lewiston Lindenhurst Liverpool Long Island City Lynbrook Mahopac Massapequa Massapequa Park Melville Merrick Middle Island Middletown Monsey Mount Kisco Mount Vernon Nanuet New Hartford New Rochelle New York Newburgh North Babylon North Bay Shore North Syracuse Nyack Oakdale Orange County Owego Oxford Palmyra Patchogue Penfield Phoenicia Plainview Plandome Plattsburgh Port Jefferson Poughkeepsie Queens Rensselaer Ridgewood Riverhead Rochester Rockville Centre Rocky Point Rome Ronkonkoma Sackets Harbor Saint James Saratoga Springs Sayville Scarsdale Selden Shortsville Side Door Hamburg Slingerlands Spring Valley Staten Island Syracuse The Bronx Tonawanda Utica Victor Wading River Watkins Glen Webster West Babylon Westbury White Plains Williamson Williamsville Wilmington Woodbury Woodmere Yonkers York Yorktown Heights

Paradise Pawnbrokers Inc

Verified

The Bronx, NY

4.3(174)

Paradise Pawnbrokers Inc. is a family-owned pawnbroker and coin dealer serving The Bronx with over 70 years of experience, offering fast cash loans from…

Park Avenue Rarities

Verified

Sayville, NY

3.2(33)

Located in Sayville, NY, this specialized coin dealer offers expert buying and selling of rare coins, collectible numismatics, and precious metals for both…

Pawn Express

Verified

Lindenhurst, NY

4.7(323)

Pawn Express is your trusted local coin dealer and numismatics specialist in Lindenhurst, NY, offering transparent evaluations and honest service since 2011.…

Pawn King

Verified

Syracuse, NY

2.0(74)

Pawn King is the #1 trusted name for buying and selling coins and numismatics in Syracuse and the Upstate New York region, offering competitive prices on…

Pawn Pro

Verified

Syracuse, NY

4.8(622)

Pawn Pro is a trusted coin dealer in Syracuse, NY offering a comprehensive selection of rare coins, collectibles, and numismatic treasures for both seasoned…

Pawn Shop NYC - Pawn Jewelry New York

Verified

New York, NY

4.9(29)

This New York coin dealer specializes in buying and selling rare coins, numismatic collectibles, and precious metals for collectors and investors throughout…

Pawn Shop of Babylon

Verified

West Babylon, NY

3.0(18)

Located in West Babylon, NY, this coin dealer specializes in numismatics and offers a comprehensive selection of coins for collectors and investors. The shop…

Pawn Stars

Verified

Rome, NY

4.3(35)

Pawn Stars in Rome, NY is your trusted local coin dealer specializing in numismatics and precious metals, offering quick and reliable pawn services with fair…

Pawn-it

Verified

Buffalo, NY

4.5(294)

Located in Buffalo, NY, Pawn-it is a trusted coin dealer specializing in numismatics and rare coins for collectors and investors. They buy and sell coins of all…

Pay More Pawn

Verified

Liverpool, NY

4.9(242)

Pay More Pawn is a trusted coin dealer in Liverpool, NY, specializing in buying and selling coins and numismatic collectibles for enthusiasts and investors…

Port Jefferson Silver and Gold Coin Store

Verified

Port Jefferson, NY

Port Jefferson's premier destination for buying and selling coins, rare numismatics, and precious metals, offering expertise in coin grading and authentication.…

Premier Coin Galleries

Verified

East Islip, NY

4.0(119)

Premier Coin Galleries is a trusted coin dealer in East Islip, NY specializing in numismatics and precious metals including gold, silver, platinum, and…

Premier Gold, Silver & Coins LLC

Verified

Cheektowaga, NY

4.8(96)

Premier Gold, Silver & Coins LLC is a trusted coin dealer in Cheektowaga, NY specializing in buying and selling coins, precious metals, and numismatic items.…

Professional Coin Galleries New York

Verified

New York, NY

3.0(15)

Professional Coin Galleries in New York, NY is a trusted coin dealer offering an extensive selection of rare coins, collectible numismatics, and precious…

Public Metal Buyers Inc

Verified

New York, NY

5.0(10)

Public Metal Buyers Inc is a coin dealer in New York, NY specializing in the buying and selling of coins and numismatic collectibles. With expertise in precious…

Queen City Antiques

Verified

Buffalo, NY

4.0(33)

Located in Buffalo, NY, Queen City Antiques is a premier coin dealer specializing in numismatics and rare coins for collectors and investors. We buy and sell…

R&S Diamond Exchange

Verified

Rocky Point, NY

4.6(128)

R&S Diamond Exchange is a family-owned and operated coin dealer and full-service jewelry store in Rocky Point, NY, serving the community since 1980 with three…

RD Precious Metals, Inc.

Verified

New York, NY

5.0(8)

RD Precious Metals, Inc. is a trusted coin dealer in New York, NY offering a comprehensive selection of rare coins, numismatic collectibles, and precious…

REBANE Bullion & More, LLC

Verified

Sackets Harbor, NY

1.0(2)

REBANE Bullion & More, LLC is a trusted coin dealer in Sackets Harbor, NY specializing in numismatics and precious metals. We buy and sell coins of all types,…

Rare Coins, Collectables

Verified

Kenmore, NY

4.2(114)

This Kenmore, NY coin dealer specializes in rare coins and collectibles for serious numismatists and investors. Rare Coins, Collectables buys and sells coins…

Rarity

Verified

Poughkeepsie, NY

Rarity is a premier coin dealer in Poughkeepsie, NY, offering an extensive selection of rare coins, numismatic collectibles, and precious metals for both…

Refine Max Inc

Verified

New York, NY

3.7(6)

Refine Max Inc is a trusted coin dealer in New York, NY offering a comprehensive selection of rare coins, collectible currency, and numismatic treasures for…

Remember Yesteryears Vintage Center

Verified

Oakdale, NY

4.7(387)

Remember Yesteryears Vintage Center is a premier coin dealer in Oakdale, NY specializing in numismatics and rare coins for collectors and enthusiasts. With a…

Retro Relics Inc

Verified

Lake Grove, NY

4.5(85)

Retro Relics Inc is a trusted coin dealer in Lake Grove, NY, offering a curated selection of coins and numismatic collectibles for both seasoned collectors and…

See New York Coin Shows →

Also browse dealers in: Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Vermont

Frequently Asked Questions

Where can I find coin dealers in New York?

There are 314 coin dealers listed in New York on US Coin Shows. Browse by city using the filters above, or search for dealers by specialty.

What do coin dealers in New York buy?

Coin dealers in New York typically buy and sell U.S. coins, world coins, paper currency, gold and silver bullion, tokens, medals, and numismatic supplies. Many also purchase estates and collections. Check individual dealer profiles for their specific specialties.

How do I sell my coins to a dealer in New York?

Find a coin dealer near you in New York using the listings above. Contact the dealer directly to arrange a meeting or bring your coins to a local coin show where multiple dealers can make offers. It's always a good idea to get multiple opinions before selling.

Are there coin shows in New York where I can meet dealers?

Yes — many coin dealers in New York attend local and regional coin shows. Visit the New York coin shows page on US Coin Shows to find upcoming events where you can meet dealers in person.

Coin Dealers in New York

Paradise Pawnbrokers Inc

Park Avenue Rarities

Pawn Express

Pawn King

Pawn Pro

Pawn Shop NYC - Pawn Jewelry New York

Pawn Shop of Babylon

Pawn Stars

Pawn-it

Pay More Pawn

Port Jefferson Silver and Gold Coin Store

Premier Coin Galleries

Premier Gold, Silver & Coins LLC

Professional Coin Galleries New York

Public Metal Buyers Inc

Queen City Antiques

R&S Diamond Exchange

RD Precious Metals, Inc.

REBANE Bullion & More, LLC

Rare Coins, Collectables

Rarity

Refine Max Inc

Remember Yesteryears Vintage Center

Retro Relics Inc

Frequently Asked Questions

Your Privacy Choices