Professional Coin Galleries in New York, NY is a trusted coin dealer offering an extensive selection of rare coins, collectible numismatics, and precious metals. We buy and sell coins of all types, from ancient pieces to modern commemoratives, serving collectors and investors throughout the New York area. Our knowledgeable staff provides expert appraisals and guidance to help you build or liquidate your collection with confidence.
Professional Coin Galleries in New York, NY is a trusted coin dealer offering an extensive selection of rare coins, collectible numismatics, and precious metals. We buy and sell coins of all types, from ancient pieces to modern commemoratives, serving collectors and investors throughout the New York area. Our knowledgeable staff provides expert appraisals and guidance to help you build or liquidate your collection with confidence.
Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.
0
Called and asked some questions and the person on the phone hung up on me. Quite the jerk.— Jamie Webb, May 2023
Saw this place on the show Impractical jokers. Would definitely check this place out.— Daniel D, Jun 2024
GREAT JOB bringing me up to speed with my new venture into Good coin IRA’S ! Thank you!— John Bosco, Aug 2021
Jimmy is an x con man from Stratton oakmont a thief low life worst of the worst has ruined people’s lives run 4 your life— Jack Viteritti, Jun 2023
Stay away from these New york/Long Island coin "dealers'. They try to sell overpriced coins as investments. The only person making money are the scam salesmen. When they caught they change company names and call you again. They'll use tactics like using a fake caller id to think they are calling you locally.— Jason Sipes, Mar 2023
In Sept. 2020 I agreed to sell back a coin to Professional Coin Galleries which I purchased from Jim Garofalo, PCG founder and owner, in 2019. I was quoted on the phone, verbally ("not in writing" Jim declares) a price for the coin. I returned the coin and the company acknowledges receipt. Six weeks later there has been no payment for the coin and after multiple inquiries Jim (finally) calls me to tell me "that the wrong price was quoted for the wrong coin." PCG has the original invoice for a coin they sold to me last year and PCG misquotes the wrong price for the wrong coin? Isn't that their "business?" And it takes six weeks to "discover" this and reveal this to me?I have neither the coin nor any payment for this coin. And let me add that an employee states a check was sent out a couple weeks ago for the coin (at 22% less than the agreed upon price!). No check was received (by me) at all although PCG has my correct mailing address. How does a 22%-under-agreed-upon-price come about? And even that doesn't happen. After 12 years in business, PCG receives Better Business Bureau accreditation in August 2020?— Diana M, Mar 2023
I spoke with Ray and the owner, James. I was impressed with the integrity of both guys. There was a misunderstanding with part of my order, and a sizeable charge was placed on my credit card for product I did not order. I had never done business with this company at this point. Not only did Ray & James honor their word, they were patient with my anxiety from large overcharge. I am a small investor and I will absolutely continue to build and create my portfolio with PCG. It has been my experience that you can trust this company. I will continue to do business with PCG. A+ !!!— Sonny J Rock, Aug 2022
You must be logged in to leave a review.
Log In to Review
