About Man Cave Comics and Collectibles

This Shelbyville, IN coin dealer specializes in numismatics and offers a curated selection of collectible coins and precious metals for both seasoned collectors and newcomers. Man Cave Comics and Collectibles buys and sells coins, providing expert appraisals and personalized service to help you build or expand your collection. Whether you're seeking rare numismatic pieces or investment-grade coins, this local shop combines knowledgeable staff with a passion for quality collectibles.

Active ListingLast verified: February 27, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0

Report a correction

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review

4.7

★★★★½

7 reviews · 4.7 (80 on Google)

5★

7

4★

0

3★

0

2★

0

1★

0

Gary HornungGoogle★★★★★Dec 2025

5 star review

— Gary Hornung, Dec 2025

Matt StuartGoogle★★★★★Feb 2026

5 star review

— Matt Stuart, Feb 2026

MegGoogle★★★★★Oct 2025

My family loves this place! Tons of comics, characters, and much more!

— Meg, Oct 2025

View on Google

Christopher McCoyGoogle★★★★★Jul 2023

Awesome Place in Shelbyville for Everything Collectable. Had an amazing time looking at everything. And the gentlemen in there are very very fairly priced. Great place to stop if you drive through Shelbyville. A++++++++++++++++++

— Christopher McCoy, Jul 2023

View on Google

Todd CurfmanGoogle★★★★★Oct 2025

Great selection of back issues! Lots of really cool items and collectibles as well. Very friendly service, definitely going back.

— Todd Curfman, Oct 2025

View on Google

Isaac MarchandGoogle★★★★★Dec 2025

Wide selection of comics that are well organized. Fair prices. Tim and Trevor are friendly and helpful. Highly recommended for comic book fans!

— Isaac Marchand, Dec 2025

View on Google

Sunny AmmermanGoogle★★★★★Jan 2026

Very charming shop. The owner is so nice and really knows his stuff! Really appreciated the vibes when we stopped in to visit on the hunt for some Magic cards. He only had a small supply of those, but kindly suggested another shop across town (LA Comics) in case they had any. They also only had a small handful of cards, but we had a nice visit there as well, and the kind sense of community between the two businesses was really nice to see. Definitely stop by and support Man Cave Comics if you can! :)

— Sunny Ammerman, Jan 2026

View on Google