Hoosier Coin Shop

Great experience! What a hidden gem. Tommy is fair and straightforward. I will be going back!

Fair and honest. Very friendly.

4 star review

Extremely fair! on some of the coins, I did not think were that big of a deal. He shocked me on the prices. I am now a lifetime customer. If you have a coin collection or currency or jewelry and you live in this area or even within an hour or so, I highly suggest going here ! well worth the trip Call to make an appointment I am already referring my friends and clients

Straightforward. Knowledgeable, trustworthy. I brought some coins by and was impressed with Tommy. We made a deal that he and I both agreed on, I’d recommend this spot to anyone.

Definitely everyone should take the gold they have here. He is extremely fair with what he pays and is very nice and the older gentleman that is there is super kind as well. Will be returning.

Just met Tommy today and have to say was very pleased with my experience! Straight shooter that pays a great price! Really informative and even offered to let me watch him closely at the coin counter that was just like 5 or 6 feet away. You won't find a more honest person to do business with! Thanks for the great experience Tommy. For sure going to recommend you to everyone!

I purchased several gold coins from them, then later sold them back. Their percentages above and below spot was consistent and fair. They were friendly and to me and seemed honest. Sadly a rarity these days.They paid 97% of spot. An hour earlier another shop offered me only 90%. A HUGE difference when gold is at $4500 One of the biggest concern one might have selling coins is are you going to get a fair price. In MY humble opinion, these guys are legit. What they tell you may or may not be what you were hoping to hear…or get paid..but I truly believe they built their business around integrity, and first and foremost want to be fair with their customers. I highly recommend them.