Midwest Fine Jewelry & Coin

Great customer service. Overall great people and prices. Glad I stopped in.

Very nice people and extremely good prices

This is an old school coin shop where businesses is earned by reputation. Bought a bunch of coins from them at reasonable prices but I usually am there a while as I end up talking and joking with them . It's more like hanging out with friends than shopping for coins .

I wanted to share my experience with this company because I felt the service and offer were very poorly reflecting the way this business runs. I came in a couple weeks back to see if there was any interest in my solid gold Cuban necklace and bracelet. And also a Rolex watch that I had owned. It came with boxing papers. As soon as I walk through the front door, I see what looks like to be the owner on the phone. He greets me. I show him the Rolex watch first. Right off the bat he goes. Oh that could be a clone that could be fake. I looked at him and said is there any way for you to determine that this isn’t. Knowing that where I purchase this from was obviously authentic. He showed zero interest and kind of shrugged it off and went back to his phone call. I spoke up and said well I wasn’t done, but did you have any interest in my gold jewelry. He then decides to finally get off of his middle of his conversation because he has some interest in the gold jewelry. He weighs it. He constantly keeps telling me well if it checks out I’d be interested at 10 K. I assume that that was a joke, but let him finish his statement. It was then that I knew that this was not an establishment that I wanted to do business with. I went 3 miles down the road and was instantly offered 18,000 for my gold. 10 minutes of my time saved me $8000. I’m not sure what kind of business this guy is running but definitely not a place where I wanna sell my gold virtual. Oh, and I sold the watch to the same person who offered me 18,000 as well. Very well established gold jeweler in Madison. Just my thoughts on this experience.

Was here today. Picked up some interesting coins for a buddy. Will be back for more. Shame they are not open on Sunday. That would be a five star review.

If you plan on selling or buying jewelry you should go here!! They treat you fairly and are better priced than any other place I've been to. The owner is legit and straight forward. It's nice not feeling ripped off. Go here! They have collectable items here as well. Great place with great people!

I brought in some coins and dollar bills to see if they had any value beyond face value. They were honest and let me know that most didn’t have significant value, which I really appreciated. They even saved me a trip to the bank by exchanging my coins for dollar bills on the spot. On top of that, they complimented my jewelry, which meant a lot since they’re heirlooms. Great experience overall—friendly, honest, and helpful.

I chose this business based on very positive Google reviews, and it was an excellent choice! The positive reviews are not exaggerating. I had some coins from family that I wanted to sell, and I was treated with fairness kindness and respect. They were a lot of fun, too! They were very open and transparent about the sales process and pricing structure as well as very knowledgeable about the collectibles business. I know I received an extremely good deal. I saw other customers treated with respect as well. They have a large selection of coins and other items for sale as well. I cannot recommend them highly enough!!