Costa's Fine Jewelry & Coins

Great people, great service, highly recommend coming in!

We absolutely love coming to Costa’s for all of our fine jewelry needs. They have a beautiful selection, and the staff are always excellent. Absolute favorite person to work with is Carly; she was always extremely helpful and patient and knowledgeable! Whenever I come back to visit my family, my mom and I make our semi an annual trip to Costa’s.

Friendly, Knowledgeable, and Trustworthy. I would highly recommend stopping by and seeing what they have to offer. GREAT Jewelry and honest pricing.

Great people to work with

I had a great experience at Costa's Fine Jewelry & Coin yesterday. I was wanting to see what the value of a coin I had was and ended up selling it to them for a very fair offer. They have a wonderful staff and I never felt pressured at all. I ended up buying a couple Christmas gifts before leaving also. I'm very happy with my experience and Costa's will be my first stop for my Jewelry and coin needs.

I came to Costas on Valentine’s Day to look for small gifts to give to my wife and daughters. Carly helped me pick out 3 bracelets that were in my budget. Not only was the price fair but the jewelry was beautiful and everyone loved what I gave them! Costas has many beautiful one of a kind pieces and I will definitely be shopping at their store in the future

Had an absolutely wonderful experience at Costa's! I recently came in for some 90% silver and ended up purchasing some brilliant-uncirculated dimes and half dollars near melt price. The staff was also very friendly and welcoming! Would rate more than 5 stars if I could

I recently sold my gold coins to Costa's Fine Jewelry and Coins in Waukesha, WI, and I couldn't be happier with the experience. Their reputation Yianni, the owner, was extremely knowledgeable and professional. Not only did he give me a very fair market price for my coins, but he also took the time to educate me on the precious metals market and provided valuable insights. His expertise and transparency made the process stress-free and enjoyable. If you're looking to buy or sell precious metals, I highly recommend Costa's Fine Jewelry and Coins. Five stars isn't enough! If you're looking for a trusted and reputable dealer, look no further than Costa's Fine Jewelry and Coins. I'm glad I went there!"

Costa's is not only the best coin shop I have ever visited, it's in the top tier of any type of business I've ever dealt with in my 54 years! Costa, Carly, Yianni and Andy have treated me like a friend rather than a customer since the first time I walked through the door. These are legitimately great people! They are also very knowledgeable, fair, and always happy to take time to talk to you. I give Costa's my highest recommendation and am so happy that a friend turned me on to this place!