Cache Valley Coins

Zero stars. One star is too much. Employee was worthless and knew absolutely nothing. Owner refused to help us and sat in his chair. Will not be back

Owner is very friendly and knowledgeable. Awesome collection of coins and unigue collectibles. Sample the local honey and you won't be disappointed!

If I could give 0 stars I definitely would. My boyfriend and I had came into David’s store. And wanted to purchase a full set of pre-33 coin. Every domination. While speaking to David I had mentioned that I had gold bars assorted grams and coin if he’d be willing to trade for partial of the full set of pre-33s and cash for the rest. He immediately said yes that he would have to hold the items to have them tested. A few days later I go in and he’s informed me that a 2g argot-heraeus 999.9% gold assay. Closed package is only 95% pure. A 1/20 (Singapore) gold coin straight from APMEX wasn’t ready weight or purity correctly. And third but not least a 1gram asahi refining 2024 is 100% fake. (1gram has been tested by xrf and is pure 999.9%AU After two weeks of having my items. He sales the pre-33s without my knowledge. Because I have reached out to asahi assay/mint about it being fake. They are extremely concerned as to where he’s getting his gold tested. Which is valley metal recycling and they use a vanta GX. Very disappointed

I am not impressed with Cache Valley Coins in the least. The owner, David, told me that my six 1921 High Relief Peace Dollars were counterfeit. However, they are not! For the life of me, I do not understand why he would make such a claim.

I have sold multiple times and it’s been very fair. Limited hours so call first & possibly make an appointment. Also, a coworker in a different state sold similar coins to me but for a much lower amount than I got here. He has always been very fair with me.

Was in the store to purchase silver and was told “I hate to rush you but I need to move on” I was planing on supporting local small business but he can keep his silver. I’ve never been treated so bad before.

Took my Necklace that we had purchased at an estate sale, to be appraised by david. david asked for my full address, and told us that it would take a week to be tested (test to see if the gold was real), I told him that we did not have the time and that it shouldn’t take more than 5 minutes to do a scratch test. He than said that he could do it really quick, he took the gold necklace and poured some sort of acid onto it, and it turned the gold completely black. We had to take it to two different places (Fast Cache Pawn, and Jerrick’s) to have it authenticated, and it turned out that the gold was real (14k). Jerrick’s, said that they would do their best to polish the gold and bring it back to its original color, however, they didn’t promise that it could be corrected. Both places said, who in their right mind would do such a thing., I did not mention any names, but at this point, I don’t want anybody to have the same experience that we had if they go to david’s store. I noticed that he has two accounts on Google so be cautious! If you have gold or anything of value, please do not take it here unless you want to get ripped off or have it destroyed! I feel like when I told him that we do not have the time to do it he purposely tried to destroy the necklace! Do not take anything here avoid this place at all cost! Take it to Jerrick’s!