Read the Gemini Evaluation of US Coin Shows
🏪

New York Coin Connection

ID: 6005 Store 523 mi from you Lake Grove, NY 11755 +1 (888) 650-6922
2.6 (15 reviews)
Share this Dealer

About New York Coin Connection

New York Coin Connection is a trusted coin dealer in Lake Grove, NY offering a wide selection of numismatic coins and precious metals for collectors and investors. We buy and sell coins of all types, including rare coins, bullion, and vintage currency, with expert appraisals and competitive pricing. Whether you're a seasoned numismatist or just starting your collection, our knowledgeable staff is ready to help you find the perfect pieces for your portfolio.

Imported Listing Last verified: February 27, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review
2.6
★★½☆☆
6 reviews · 2.8 (9 on Google)
5
2
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
4
Sinclair
Sinclair Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Fantastic company Have used them many times every time I call I get first class service they educate you on the process and they’re always available

adam delfino
adam delfino Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

I’ve been dealing with NYCC for a long time now. They have a great staff that is very courteous and are very knowledgeable in rare and numismatic coins, not to mention their prices can not be beat. They have made me a lot of money throughout the time I’ve been dealing with them. I would recommend them to anyone no matter where you live, whether your just looking for specific coins to complete a collection or your trying to invest in gold and silver NYCC has the highest quality coins and will be right by your side the whole way they’re just a phone call away. Thank you guys and great job!!!

View on Google
Tracie Edstrom
Tracie Edstrom Google ★☆☆☆☆ 1mo ago

This organization and the people in it should be arrested and charged criminally for crimes against the elderly. The elderly grew up in a trusting environment and I know someone in his 80's that was promised to be paid $100k for his silver. Being trusting as he is, he sent 2500 ounces of silver to this group and never got paid anything. Never do business with this group. Hopefully law enforcement will get involved and arrest all parties involved.

View on Google
Amy Wright
Amy Wright Google ★☆☆☆☆ 1mo ago

If there was a way to give 100,000 negative stars, I would. Run do not walk from this place! Do everything you can to protect your elderly family and friends from this place! You and your beloved ones will lose everything as did my father. They do not honor their word at all and stole $100,000 worth of silver from my elderly disabled vet and father. Theft is defined as taking someone’s property without permission. Andrew promised to send all of my father’s silver back if he didn’t approve. (Adam the owner likes to talk big and all; he is nothing more than a bully. Andrew is Adam’s lackie.) They could have as instructed to do so send all the silver back but instead they did whatever they wanted with my dad’s property. My father never approved or gave permission to sell any of his silver. It’s been 3 weeks since they scammed my father. I beg you do not trust either one of these guys or this place. Go to an honest, reputable precious metal broker.

View on Google
Christi Puckett
Christi Puckett Google ★☆☆☆☆ 1mo ago

New York Coin Connection, should be shut down immediately. It is a travesty and criminal, to prey on older and disadvantaged people. How is it possible, that they take someone’s belongings and never pay for them? They took advantage of a Veteran and a disabled, elderly man. Told him to send his silver and then they would pay him for it. They knew that they weren’t going to pay him, they knew that they were trying to STEAL his stuff. He was told to send his silver and coins and that they would send him $100000 for it. It’s been almost a month and no response, no money and no contact. Shame on you New York Coin Connection. Shame on anyone who works for you, shame on anyone who partners with you and shame on anyone who doesn’t expose them. Send this man his money ASAP or the next call is to my friends in the FBI…that’s a promise.

View on Google
Ansermo Arthur (Clark)
Ansermo Arthur (Clark) Google ★☆☆☆☆ 1mo ago

Buyers beware !!!! Choose another company , or you will regret ever having done business with these crooks. The hard sell is an understatement . They will not take no for an answer and browbeat you until you just finally give up and acquiesce to the constant barrage to sell you something . Not to mention after making the sale charging my account $7000, and not hearing anything from them for almost 30 days I cancelled my order . I let them know in no uncertain terms I was no longer interested . Despite my objections , and asking for a refund, they sent the coins anyway, and included 2 newly minted worthless 2024 silver eagles as though that was going to satisfy me. Then if that was not enough the return policy has a 25% restocking fee, something which I was never told about. Take my advice this company belongs in the" avoid at all cost" junk pile of companies not to do business with . Save yourself some headache go with another company. If I could give zero stars I would. Ansermo L. Arthur MD FACC

View on Google

Write a Review

You must be logged in to leave a review.

Log In to Review