Huntington Stamp & Coin

5 star review

Very professional and well-run establishment. You can tell that the owner, Brian, knows the business through and through. I learned a lot about coin grading and checking for counterfeits. Got a very fair deal on a collection that I inherited from my late grandfather. Very pleased with my experience here, thanks for everything!

I am beyond words how disappointed I am with the experience I had with these guys. I purchased an item from their eBay website and they ended up refunding my money, and gave me no reason. I later looked at their website and noticed they put the same exact coin up but at a higher price. They didn’t like the price at which they sold it to me and refunded my money. I contacted the seller and they never responded. These guys are a garbage coin dealer. BEWARE!!

Brian was pleasant, patient, knowledgeable, and straightforward. He provided a honest evaluation of my coin collection. My experience was a good one. It is easy and my pleasure to offer a 5 star rating.

It's a sad thing that stamp & coin collecting is not the draw (or the investment) that it used to be when I was growing up. And when I recently inherited my father's collection, I did not know where to turn. Do we throw it all away in the trash (heartbreaking), or do we try to give it a new home (hopeful)? I made an appointment to meet with Brian and show him the collection; a carload, four milk-crates of albums and assorted boxes of random loose stamps, all collected by my father over his long lifetime. Brian could have laughed us out the door with this stuff, but he was welcoming and knowledgeable. He instantly knew what kind of collector my father was (not an investor), and after quickly examining the lot of it he offered us a fair price. Not looking for a windfall, we just wanted the security of knowing that my father's stuff would find a new home somewhere, and not end up in a dumpster. Brian gave us hope for this. Some reviews here complain of bad behavior or disagreements, but maybe you expected too much of your old collections? We found Brian's honesty and candor completely refreshing. He's an old-school gentleman, just like the stamp dealers I remember dealing with when I was a young collector. The shrinking world of stamp & coin collecting is a better place for men like Brian and die-hard shops like Huntington Stamp & Coin. Thank you so much for this experience.

Sold some silver here today and had a great experience. They offered a fair price and the staff was incredibly nice.