Read the Gemini Evaluation of US Coin Shows
Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay logo

Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay

ID: 5993 Store 493 mi from you Lynbrook, NY 11563 +1 (516) 324-2750
3.7 (29 reviews)
Share this Dealer

About Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay

Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay has been a trusted coin dealer in Lynbrook, NY since 1974, offering nearly five decades of expertise in buying and selling rare coins, gold, silver, and fine jewelry. Their experienced team provides personalized service to both seasoned collectors and newcomers, combining deep numismatic knowledge with a commitment to honest, fair transactions. With additional locations in Oyster Bay and Levittown, they're your local partner for precious metals and numismatic investments.

Imported Listing Last verified: February 27, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review
3.7
★★★½☆
6 reviews · 4.0 (23 on Google)
5
2
4
0
3
0
2
1
1
3
elliot muller
elliot muller Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

5 star review

Craig Fowler
Craig Fowler Google ★☆☆☆☆ 1mo ago

To call this place a coin gallery is a misnomer. Very few actual coins (mostly bullion). Only one person working there who didn't know any of the prices on any coins and thus was unable to sell any. Go elsewhere if you are a collector.

View on Google
IntensityMartialArts
IntensityMartialArts Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

We had a great, informative visit with Rich today! He really helped out my son by answering a bunch of coin questions and offering us a great deal on some old coins. He made my family feel welcome, and my 7yr old left with a huge smile & some great old coins for his collection!

View on Google
thenightgallerycafe nightgallerycafe
thenightgallerycafe nightgallerycafe Google ★☆☆☆☆ 1mo ago

I’m a gold and silver stacker and just had experience in Lynbrook, with sales person called ira I would never deal or go in that store ever again and unfortunately, they lost a gigantic customer. I will bring my business elsewhere. They should look into hiring people that are professional and know how to treat a customer.

View on Google
M 7
M 7 Google ★☆☆☆☆ 1mo ago

Offered me 30x on face value for constitutional silver, which they kept referring to as "junk",that they justified by claiming refiners are backed up... as if 90% gets refined and isnt incredibly liquid. Today's spot is $95+. Anything less than 60x face is predatory. Will be selling privately instead. Also, they outright rejected the term "trade" and immediately reframed the discussion as 2 transactions, essentially insisting on maximum spread. This is not the shop for serious stackers, it's a pawn for desperate people who arent informed.

View on Google
EE GG
EE GG Google ★★☆☆☆ 1mo ago

Nice friendly people. Not much in stock and still very disorganized good place for information for ancestor questions. Know your prices before you go. Shop around. Usually better deals elsewhere.

View on Google

Write a Review

You must be logged in to leave a review.

Log In to Review