About Canandaigua Jewelry and Coin Exchange

Canandaigua Jewelry & Coin Exchange is your trusted coin dealer in Canandaigua, NY, offering a broad assortment of ever-changing inventory at low prices with knowledgeable sales associates ready to assist. We specialize in buying and selling coins, numismatics, and precious metals while providing consignment services that ensure customer satisfaction and profitable returns. Visit our impressive showroom to discover why we're the number one choice for numismatists and collectors seeking quality items and exceptional deals.

Active ListingLast verified: February 27, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0

Official Source →Report a correction

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review

4.6

★★★★½

7 reviews · 4.5 (52 on Google)

5★

7

4★

0

3★

0

2★

0

1★

0

Edwin DejesusGoogle★★★★★Nov 2025

5 star review

— Edwin Dejesus, Nov 2025

Ray Deyo Technical Solutions LLCGoogle★★★★★Dec 2025

5 star review

— Ray Deyo Technical Solutions LLC, Dec 2025

andrew alloccoGoogle★★★★★Oct 2017

Dave and team were extremely knowledgeable and professional. Dave was always helpful without feeling pressured. I had some old gold chains that I haven't worn in years so I called Canandaigua Jewelry and I was pleasantly surprised on how much he offered me. His offer was much better than anyone in Rochester. It was worth the 45 minute drive. I would highly recommend Dave and Canandaigua Jewelry. They were fantastic!

— andrew allocco, Oct 2017

View on Google

Jennifer VerdiGoogle★★★★★Sep 2025

First time visiting this business and I’ll be back! Competitive pricing and owner was knowledgeable and friendly.

— Jennifer Verdi, Sep 2025

View on Google

Steve DoodianGoogle★★★★★Oct 2025

Staff is fantastic and fair! very knowledgeable and thorough. Highly recommend!!

— Steve Doodian, Oct 2025

View on Google

Kristen McIntyreGoogle★★★★★Apr 2025

Updated 4.14.25 - Another quick, honest and professional transaction with Dave at Canandaigua Jewelry and Coin. Highly recommend them once again! Easiest long distance transaction ever! Shipped estate goods I needed liquidated after connecting with Dave last year while in NY. Friendly, honest, communicative and he gave me a great deal. I highly recommend doing business with them!

— Kristen McIntyre, Apr 2025

View on Google