Buy Your Coins

I can't say enough about doing business with Mike. I've sold him several coins and he's always very prompt, reasonable, and friendly. I'm hoping to make some purchases from him in the near future. He's got some really great prices and coins, and you don't usually find this kind of hospitality in this market.

Just received my order in the mail - very prompt, well packaged, and beautiful coins, both mint and circulated silver and rare coins, well displayed! Great people to do business with - Thank you!

A real pro, just got some great looking Morgan dollars from Mike at a great price. I feel like I learned a lot about silver just by talking to him. Seller or a buyer give him a call, this dude knows his stuff, his advice will will save you money.

5 star review

Great selling experience. Fair and friendly.

I've known Michael for over 30 years and can personally attest to his integrity - when dealing with him on anything, you're going to get honesty and professionalism. When purchasing and selling coins, ethics are key and with Michael, you can guarantee the highest standards.

Michael is a courteous and knowledgeable businessman. He and his family have been in the Watkins Glen area for 30 years and have maintained a high level of quality and integrity in all there business dealings. I would highly recommend Michael!!! Chris-Toronto, Ontario

After collecting Morgan Dollars for almost 50 years I had decided to start to sell off parts of my collection in retirement . Then the BIG question was who do I contact that will give me a fair price and not want me to ship my coins to them for an appraisal . I came across ( Buy Your Coins ) on Facebook and sent Mike Kaufman a message . He agreed to drive to Rochester to meet me and appraise my coins over dinner . It was so satisfying to talk to Mike as he has a passion for coins like I have and we talked coins over dinner for 2-hours . Mike made me an offer on all the coins I brought after explaining what he thought the value of each coin was . I was VERY satisfied with his offer as I know Blue - Gray sheet & retail on all my coins . A week later after my call Mike bought another of my coins at my asking price ! I will be going to Mike to liquidate more of my Morgans over the next few years and respect & admire him both as a Dealer and now a Friend . I highly recommend anyone selling their coins to contact him !!!

Recently purchased several coins from Mike. So happy I came across his company. He's a real pleasure to do business with and has an extensive inventory. Coins are sent immediately and packed to perfection. Mike is very fair and honest. I'll be coming back for more. Keep up the great work!

I have known Michael for 25 years. His family has owned businesses in the Watkins Glen area for over 30 years. He is known for honesty, integrity and quality. In over 100 transactions with Mike through the years, he has always been highly respected, pays for his goods and services faster than 80 percent of my clients. I recommend him highly as a fellow businessman with 35 years myself. Anyone who accuses him of anything other than being 100 percent reputable does not know the same person. I would stake my entire 35 year reputation on it.