American Rare Coin & Jewelry

The best coin dealer in K.C. .

Honest Dealer, Great Customer Service. Better than a Banker!

Very nice to deal with, very informative professional.

When I arrived at store johm greeted me kindly and ask what could he assist me with and looked over my coins carefully to make sure he would have me his best offer. I would consider coming here again to sell my coins

They are closed for Christmas 12/22-12/29 Small handwritten note on the door. I’m giving 5 Stars because I’m sure they deserve it when they are open. However I really wish the owner would have updated their hours here on Google Maps and saved me the drive.

My wife had a wonderful experience selling my jewelry here. The jeweler was very honest, transparent, and gave me a fair price for my gold and coin. He took the time to explain everything clearly and made me feel comfortable with the process. I really appreciate the excellent customer service and professionalism. Highly recommended!”

I had an excellent sales experience. Owner, John, was very knowledgeable about my coins (gol and silver), transparent about the appraisal process, and paid fair price. Highly recommended.

They will not verify authenticity of their precious metals with instrumentation (Metalytics Precious Metal Verifier or equivalent.) This is what I was told by the proprietor (October 2025.) It should be addressed to build trust and this must be a baseline regardless of what he says about his knowledge and experience. We are in a low trust society, unfortunately. If you SELL to him or any dealer, you can bet THEY will protect themselves by testing for authenticity. You should do the same. “Mind your business.” (Benjamin Franklin) Wrote this for seniors and anyone who could be naive. Address it and I’ll revise the review.