Read the Gemini Evaluation of US Coin Shows
Premier Arms, LLC logo

Premier Arms, LLC

ID: 4852 Sporting Goods Store 181 mi from you Brownsburg, IN 46112 +1 (317) 858-3030
4.2 (165 reviews)
Share this Dealer

About Premier Arms, LLC

Premier Arms, LLC in Brownsburg, IN is the Midwest's largest state and federally licensed firearms dealer, stocking over 1,700 new and used firearms along with a comprehensive selection of knives from authorized Benchmake and Microtech dealers. As a premier buyer and seller of firearms, militaria, gold and silver bullion, and estate jewelry, this established dealer serves collectors and investors throughout the region. Visit their Green Street location to buy and sell coins, precious metals, and other valuable collectibles with expert numismatic knowledge.

Imported Listing Last verified: February 27, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review
4.2
★★★★☆
10 reviews · 4.2 (155 on Google)
5
8
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
2
Russell Pickett
Russell Pickett Google ★☆☆☆☆ 1mo ago

I have never felt so disrespected by someone. Was interested in maybe selling a couple guns. I sold one here before and bought some here before. The customer service has slowly been declining. Wasn’t sure what the market was like . So I asked for a value and what I could get. When I didn’t divulge what I wanted for them. You could tell his demeanor changed and he became aloof. After reading other reviews, this seems to be this guy’s M.O. (honestly that is what spurred me to write a review, to echo and validate what others have said as true) Then when he went to “check their stock”. Apparently they can’t afford computers or a spreadsheet program. Which would be smart considering ATF requires you to keep a register of your inventory. Then he came back and let me know they weren’t interested. I wasted an hour of my time on my day off. It’s not a giant warehouse, I’m sure you’re aware of how many rimfire rifles you have on hand. Again, even if you don’t. A simple spreadsheet would save you a lot of time. Could have had some integrity and just came out and said if you won’t tell me what you want we won’t make an offer. I could respect that. It’s like they don’t understand haggling. If you weren’t in the market for them you’d know that instantly. But I appreciate you inspecting the guns you weren’t interested in buying and dry firing both of these rimfires. Especially the vintage one you can’t get parts for easily. I’d rather chop them in half then sell them to you and won’t be surprised when Sportman’s puts you out of business. I won’t ever waste my time coming back. Sad when you can get treated better at a big box vs what I’d prefer to do and shop local. Also I encourage anyone reading this review to read the others like mine. It also seems to be standard procedure for them to “review the security footage” then blame the customer on here in their response to their subpar customer service complaints. Which is extremely concerning. So they are attaching your name to the time stamp on their security footage apparently. So how else would they know of all the people who come in there. Which encounter is who’s based solely on a google reviewer’s name. As 2A proponents this company should NOT be trusted by us. Absolutely disgusting behavior and I’m sure if pressed by the government. For sure, they’d be the first to sell out their customers.

Steve Johnson
Steve Johnson Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Clean, well managed, shop with fair pricing and friendly staff.

Makayla Birchman
Makayla Birchman Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Always a great experience. Did the kiosk for my background and was very easy. The men are always nice and helpful. They will always have my business.

Alex Kelley
Alex Kelley Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

5 star review

Zach Rudolph
Zach Rudolph Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Lot's of merchandise, but sometimes difficult to get help. I'll add this is mostly just due to the fact that they are busy. Prices seem average for what I've seen other gun shops locally. Great knives too! Went back and had excellent customer service. Was able to sell one of my guns and Brad was very helpful and professional.

Chris May
Chris May Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

This amazing Gun Shop is a daily stop on my treasure hunts. The employees have always been helpful and knowledgeable. The Owner has provided both a friendly and family oriented environment! The selection is always changing, which is why I have to stop by so much! The accessories and ammo selection will provide all your needs and they are happy to look online if needed! P.S. The jewelry is just another treasure chest within this establishment to check out. Approved by Modern Pirate Lord

View on Google
Aherold 1990
Aherold 1990 Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Awesome place to sell and buy firearms. Sold a firearm of mine and was given a fair price and the prices on their firearms are reasonable, large selection of firearms, accessories, and loading powder,primers etc. Staff was very friendly as well I will be making my future firearm and firearm related purchases from them from now on.

View on Google
Brian Goode
Brian Goode Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Great place to purchase a firearm, knowledgeable and friendly staff. Awesome selection of guns, ammo and knives. They even have a decent selection of cigars. My new favorite place to shop.

View on Google
B. David Hansen
B. David Hansen Google ★☆☆☆☆ 1mo ago

I’ve bought several firearms from here. I brought back a firearm to sell that I bought from Premier and the older man (not owner) was completely dismissive and rude. I wasn’t looking for a return, I just wanted to buy a different firearm. The man told me that they already had one in stock so they weren’t interested. — Three months later I went back to sell a different firearm from my collection and was greeted with the same gentleman with the same rude dismissive, disrespectful attitude. I refuse to go back. There are better options and customer service in Avon and Lizton that actually appreciate your business and the money you spend. — Stay away unless you want to feel like a burden.

View on Google
Rick Masters
Rick Masters Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Great guys at Premier Arms! They were super helpful and patient . The store was well organized. I highly recommend this place for all your firearms needs! The Ruger AR556 with the Romeo and Juliet Sig optics was just what I wanted! Light weight and functional AR platform with lots of options. Thanks PA!

View on Google

Write a Review

You must be logged in to leave a review.

Log In to Review