Coin and Jewelry Gallery of Boca Raton

Brought my coins in to get checked out. Gary was awesome!! He took his time to review and appraise my coins. Great local coin shop.

Awesome people and terrific service. I will highly recommend anyone who wants to buy or sell gold and silver to check these guys out.

5 star review

It was my first time at Coin and Jewelry. Gary was great. Very nice and courteous. Gary let me go through his different silver coins until I found what I was looking for. The prices were great. I have found my new go to coin shop. I will be back.

Gary was clear and human with me. I sold my $20 Liberty Gold Double Eagle coin for a fair price; I had gotten a few quotes before coming to Gary. The store was full too which I think is a good sign. Overall really happy with the whole experience.

I can’t say enough about Gary at Coin and Jewelry Gallery. In a business where honesty and trust are everything, Gary is a true standout. He is straightforward, knowledgeable, and takes the time to explain values, pricing, and market trends in a way that makes you feel comfortable and confident. There’s never any pressure—just genuine guidance and fairness in every transaction. Gary’s integrity and professionalism set the bar high. Whether you’re buying or selling, you can trust that he’ll treat you with respect and keep your best interests in mind. I highly recommend Coin and Jewelry Gallery to anyone looking for an honest and reliable dealer.

Called them up, and spoke with Anthony who was helpful and informed on the phone. When I came in, I met him and the owner Gary. Again, both were extremely friendly and more than fair in their pricing. They were straight shooters and I would absolutely use them again for both buying and selling. A gem of an lcs I was previously unaware of, but very happy to discover.

I came with some valuable coins and jewelry to see Gary Tancer, December 2025 in West Boca Raton. As a result, Gary gave me an incredible price on all of my coins and gold and silver. He spent the time to review all the coins and rings and wrote me a check on the spot. The amount was considerably more than I ever would have expected. Looking forward to going back to work with Gary again. Highly recommend his service and the location was perfect and I parked right in front. Thanks again Gary! Kudos!

We came in to sell silver and gold today and it was a really good experience. The gentleman was really nice and was very nice to talk to. I sent my girlfriend in the past and the guy that was helping her took his time and was honest and didn’t try to take advantage of her which I really appreciated. It was a great experience and I would recommend to take your business to them.