Shorewood Coin Shop is your trusted coin dealer in Shorewood, WI, specializing in numismatics and rare coins for collectors and investors alike. Located in this vibrant urban suburb just north of Milwaukee, we offer expert buying and selling of coins and precious metals to serve our community's numismatic needs. Visit our shop to explore quality coins, build your collection, and receive professional guidance from experienced numismatists.
Shorewood Coin Shop is your trusted coin dealer in Shorewood, WI, specializing in numismatics and rare coins for collectors and investors alike. Located in this vibrant urban suburb just north of Milwaukee, we offer expert buying and selling of coins and precious metals to serve our community's numismatic needs. Visit our shop to explore quality coins, build your collection, and receive professional guidance from experienced numismatists.
Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.
0
5 star review— Emil Ibe, May 2025
I have some old coins and I would like to know if you could help me by seeing what their current value is.— Nemesio Pinzón, Jul 2025
Very good 👍— Efraín Galvan, Oct 2025
5 star review— Mary Nfunde, Jan 2026
Great store with great prices and a huge inventory. Easily some of the most friendly and knowledgeable staff I've ever run into. Been coming here since I was 8 and I've always left knowing that I got the best prices for my coins, hands down!— Will Schires, Oct 2023
Super friendly, easy and FAIR experience! Had heard good things about the guys down at Shorewood Coin and they weren't wrong. Polite and friendly, explained why the prices offered were the way they were. Even offered some direction on other antiques I am looking to sell. Definitely would come back and would definitely recommend you check them out before other stores.— Angela Scharber, Apr 2017
Honest, respectable people selling high quality product with reasonable premiums.— Peter Crawford-Vukicevic, Aug 2025
Came in with a sorted 10,000 coin family collection and Nick, Jeff & Alex stayed late and had it completely appraised in 90 minutes. They know their stuff! I agree with the reviews about fair pricing and very friendly service. I left very satisfied, and with their trusted contact information for a dealer interested in another collection I am selling. Don’t understand the reviews bashing the shop appearance … it isn’t a beauty parlor, but it’s exactly what I would expect for a family run small coins and collectibles shop.— Jim Bury, Feb 2022
Jeff took his time, and it was a long time, to both go through my Dad's coin collection and also educate me on what was of value and why. I appreciated his up front approach and was very happy with the results. Thank you Shorewood Coin Shop!— Jean Rowinski, May 2025
You must be logged in to leave a review.
Log In to Review
