About Old Fort Coin Exchange

Old Fort Coin Exchange in Jefferson, WI is a premier coin dealer specializing in numismatics with over 15 years of expertise in coins from various eras and regions. Owner Eric Stone is passionate about helping both new and experienced collectors build their collections while sharing knowledge about the historical significance and craftsmanship of rare coins. Located at 320 Wisconsin Drive, this ANA-certified dealer buys and sells coins with an constantly changing inventory, so call or visit the store for the latest arrivals.

Active ListingLast verified: February 26, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0

Official Source →Report a correction

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review

5.0

★★★★★

8 reviews · 5.0 (24 on Google)

5★

8

4★

0

3★

0

2★

0

1★

0

Diana StikaGoogle★★★★★Nov 2025

5 star review

— Diana Stika, Nov 2025

Thomas RodeGoogle★★★★★Nov 2025

Great appraisal, cash offered, knowledgeable person.

— Thomas Rode, Nov 2025

charles wallaceGoogle★★★★★Nov 2025

Very friendly and knowledgeable owner. Has a good selection of coins.

— charles wallace, Nov 2025

Erich UtrieGoogle★★★★★Jan 2026

A great little shop filled with currency and other interesting artifacts. The owner was very knowledgeable and cool to talk with.

— Erich Utrie, Jan 2026

View on Google

loganlarkGoogle★★★★★Oct 2025

Family friendly - great place to get kids inspired to start coin collecting. Plus some nice vintage military items. Great experience here.

— loganlark, Oct 2025

View on Google

Randy DartyGoogle★★★★★Aug 2025

I was in the area for business and googled “coin shops”, found this place and I stopped in. I left with a couple nice Morgans at a fair price. I talked to owner Eric for a while, real nice guy and very knowledgeable. I am looking forward to my next visit.

— Randy Darty, Aug 2025

View on Google

Chuck BlockGoogle★★★★★Nov 2025

Eric the store owner is very knowledgeable and helpful. Prices have always been fair. If looking for a local coin shop I would highly recommend the Old Fort Coin Exchange.

— Chuck Block, Nov 2025

View on Google

James McDGoogle★★★★★Jan 2026

Had the day off and decided to make the drive from Madison. Well worth it. Excellent prices. Smaller shop but lots of things I was interested in. Friendly owner. I will be back!

— James McD, Jan 2026

View on Google