Collector's Choice Coins

Name: Collector's Choice Coins
Address: 131 King St, Sun Prairie, WI, 53590, US
Telephone: +1 (608) 834-4114
Rating: 4.8

ID: 1314Store391 mi from youSun Prairie, WI 53590 +1 (608) 834-4114

Collector's Choice Coins, a trusted coin dealer in Sun Prairie, WI since 1988, specializes in hunting elusive numismatic items for discerning collectors while building lasting relationships through expert knowledge and passion for the hobby. Owner John Krueger is dedicated to teaching new and young collectors about coins and helping them start their collecting journey in a friendly, welcoming environment. With locations in both Sun Prairie and Portage, this coin gallery buys and…

4.8(45 reviews)

Share this Dealer

About Collector's Choice Coins

Active ListingLast verified: February 26, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

Official Source →Report a correction

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review

4.8

★★★★☆

8 reviews · 4.8 (37 on Google)

5★

4★

3★

2★

1★

John GruenenfelderGoogle★★★★★Nov 2025

5 star review

— John Gruenenfelder, Nov 2025

Stefanie MurnaneGoogle★★★★★Dec 2025

5 star review

— Stefanie Murnane, Dec 2025

MatthewGoogle★★★★★Jan 2026

Fair and honest. Highly recommend.

— Matthew, Jan 2026

Kathleen BermanGoogle★★★★★Aug 2022

We brought in a box of older coins that belonged to my mother. Tom and Dan were very helpful and explained the value of each coin - and why it was so We sold most of the collection at a very fair price. As a bonus, we met the very sweet onsite dog. Recommend this local store - friendly, honest and knowledgeable. Thanks!

— Kathleen Berman, Aug 2022

View on Google

Emily WitkiewiczGoogle★★★★★Feb 2021

My son is young coin collector and each time we have gone into the store John is a very kind and patient with him. His coin prices are very reasonable! He answers his questions, teaches him, and gets him more excited about coins. We feel lucky to have such a great coin shop in Sun Prairie! He can't wait to save up more money to go back;)

— Emily Witkiewicz, Feb 2021

View on Google

Scott nimmoGoogle★★★★★Feb 2025

I’ve been dealing with collectors choice for over ten years. The prices are fair and I trust the owner. I just saw him at the coin show over the weekend, he had a great display of any coin you’re looking for!

— Scott nimmo, Feb 2025

View on Google

Nikolaos KaravergosGoogle★★★★★Jul 2025

Very honest group of people who helped make for a seamless process. Got some great insight into the coin collection I brought in and got a very fair value. Will be back!!

— Nikolaos Karavergos, Jul 2025

View on Google

Sheree GieglingGoogle★★★★★Aug 2025

We had various pieces of jewelry that we wanted to sell. John took his time to sort through everything and gave us a good price. Very easy to work with and communicated well. We will be returning, and highly recommend.

— Sheree Giegling, Aug 2025

View on Google