This West Bend, WI coin dealer specializes in numismatics and precious metals, offering a curated selection of coins for collectors and investors alike. American Coins & Jewelry buys and sells coins of all types, providing fair valuations and expert guidance for both seasoned numismatists and newcomers to the hobby. Whether you're looking to expand your collection or liquidate coins, this trusted local dealer delivers professional service and competitive pricing.
This West Bend, WI coin dealer specializes in numismatics and precious metals, offering a curated selection of coins for collectors and investors alike. American Coins & Jewelry buys and sells coins of all types, providing fair valuations and expert guidance for both seasoned numismatists and newcomers to the hobby. Whether you're looking to expand your collection or liquidate coins, this trusted local dealer delivers professional service and competitive pricing.
Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.
0
Stopped by during business hours and the shop was completely closed. No lights on, called the number and nobody answered— Sara R, Jun 2025
He sells Trump coins and says that they are pure silver but they are not! Crooked as can be. I can't give less than one star— Donald Wollersheim, Aug 2025
2 star review— dan demeulenaere, Dec 2025
Extremely rude and condescending. Avoid at all costs.— Jacob Carpenter, Feb 2026
Rude and overpriced. He would talk over me. He inferred I that I was stupid for buying coins online. He mocked a customer who came in earlier in the day with fake silver coins. He didn't offer to show me anything until I told him what I wanted to spend. I did not do my homework before going in and he charged me almost double what google says is the going rate for silver half dollars. I will not go there again. Spend your money with someone who appreciates you.— Andrew B, Mar 2022
been there a few times and the guy needs some serious anger management professional help. never met an owner who embodied immaturity, rudeness, arrogance, anger, and bully factor. I'd sell to other places at a lower price than deal with him.— mrod2811, Apr 2025
Went in here and started asking about some scrap silver he instantly started to be little me and sarcasticlly started acting like i was telling him how to do his job. Hands down the worst gold and silver shop owner ive meet. Its sad a space on main is wasted on such people.— Kent Nicholson, Nov 2025
He said $40-$50 for my bayonet and it just sold on eBay for $160.! I understand he needs to make money, but holy wow, at least coulda offered me $80.! I was hoping he would buy my rings and resell. But would only give me money for the gold. Hit me up on Facebook Marketplace ...— Shelly “Miss Smith Lake” Baird, Jun 2024
You must be logged in to leave a review.
Log In to Review