🏪

PJ Beiter Coins

ID: 3367Store327 mi from youWilliamsport, PA 17701+1 (570) 279-2128

PJ Beiter Coins is a trusted coin dealer located at 208 Pine Street in Williamsport, PA, operated by Paula Beiter with decades of numismatic expertise inherited from her father Bob's coin collecting legacy. The shop buys and sells coins while maintaining a strong presence at coin shows throughout Pennsylvania and neighboring states, offering customers fair pricing and reliable service. With both a physical storefront and online e-commerce platform at PJBeiterCoins.com, PJ Beiter…

4.5(28 reviews)
Share this Dealer

About PJ Beiter Coins

PJ Beiter Coins is a trusted coin dealer located at 208 Pine Street in Williamsport, PA, operated by Paula Beiter with decades of numismatic expertise inherited from her father Bob's coin collecting legacy. The shop buys and sells coins while maintaining a strong presence at coin shows throughout Pennsylvania and neighboring states, offering customers fair pricing and reliable service. With both a physical storefront and online e-commerce platform at PJBeiterCoins.com, PJ Beiter Coins provides convenient access to quality coins and numismatic goods for collectors and investors.

Active ListingLast verified: February 26, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review
4.5
★★★★½
8 reviews · 4.4 (20 on Google)
5
6
4
2
3
0
2
0
1
0
Beverly Smith
Beverly SmithGoogle★★★★★
The ladies were efficiencies and very helpful. Thank you ladies for your help.
— Beverly Smith, Sep 2023
Ronald Graw
Ronald GrawGoogle★★★★★
5 star review
— Ronald Graw, Jun 2024
Geniel Miller
Geniel MillerGoogle★★★★★
5 star review
— Geniel Miller, Apr 2025
Francis Burke
Francis BurkeGoogle★★★★☆
Paula carries mostly U.S. coins for the collectors and also gold and silver bullion for the investor. She carries a very well stocked inventory of supplies as welk.
— Francis Burke, Aug 2021
path snyder
path snyderGoogle★★★★★
Absolute professional with highest level of integrity that I have encountered in a very long time. I have personally bought and sold coins and bars with different dealers over the years and without I doubt it will be a fair and square deal. I will be using PJ Beiter for all purchases.
— path snyder, Oct 2021
Darren Mertz
Darren MertzGoogle★★★★★
Super fair buyer. My mother had no need for my father's collection after his passing. Neither of us had any idea what it was worth other than the 'scrap' value of the silver. Most of the coins were very worn and a lesser buyer could have given me market value for the whole lot and I would have been none the wiser. Paula was very thorough. She went through the whole lot coin by coin. She found some gems among the pile and payed for those appropriately. Very happy with the whole experience.
— Darren Mertz, Sep 2014
Jesse S
Jesse SGoogle★★★★☆
Register people were nice. But not a place you want to go if you got double stamped 50 cent pieces or serial number errors on paper dollars. Plenty of made in China mickey mouse $100 bills if you're into those types of products. Some older US minted bills and coins great prices if you want to try to get a kid into coin collecting though. Don't bring up tax loopholes they get testy. No silver certificates or gold certificates in stocks when I was there. If trying to buy metal as an investment check Costco prices first.
— Jesse S, Jan 2024
uc drock
uc drockGoogle★★★★★
Great place to start or improve a collection! Staff is extremely helpful and friendl! Great deals too
— uc drock, Oct 2025

Write a Review

You must be logged in to leave a review.

Log In to Review