PA Collectors Society

Great place, Spencer was more than honest and fair. Thank you!

5 star review

I was at the Sellinsgrove office today looking to sell my coin collection. The staff was very inviting and great to work with. They were up-front with how they would be pricing my collection. They were very thorough and did not try to rip me off. I was very please with their offer. I would recommend them to anyone looking to buy or sell.

Spencer was very honest and knowledgeable. He explained which of my items were valuable and which were not and why they were valuable. He gave me very fair prices. He even accommodated me with a Saturday morning appointment. I will definitely deal with him in the future.

The staff was very helpful and pleasant. Definitely paid out top dollar on gold. I would definitely go there again. I would recommend any one in the market for jewelry or to cash in gold to definitely go here.

I came here to sell an old engagement ring and had great service. I called first and spoke with Spencer who gave me tons of information and advice. When I made it into the store Devon is who I spoke with and she was very helpful and knowledgeable. She gave me a lot of information and was honest about the value of rings/materials. If I ever have something that I’d like to sell again I’ll come here. Even if you are looking for just information both Devon and Spencer are very helpful and great people to do business with ☺️

Visited the shop today for the first time. Had some old coins from my mother's estate I wanted to get checked out. I was pleased with the offer they made on them. Also gave me some tips on spotting coins that could be of value that I had no idea about. The lady who helped me was very knowledgeable and friendly. I will be back for sure

I’ve always wanted to get into collecting silver, and a coworker helped me get my foot in the door. He told me about Spencer and the shop he runs down in Selinsgrove. I had no clue about silver, gold, or anything of that sort. I got in contact with Spencer to learn how the whole process works, and he took time out of his morning to talk with me on the phone about pricing and the methods they use. We were on the phone for about 30 minutes, and not once did I feel rushed. He explained everything in depth, asked if I had any questions, and covered all the topics I needed to know. I was recently laid off just before the holidays and wanted to get my wife a nice present this year, so I took a small amount of silver and a couple of other pieces down to his shop to see what he could do. He was very reasonable with his prices, and I was able to get the funds needed to make that present happen. Growing up around Williamsport, I used to visit gold and silver stores and always thought their prices were outrageous. I’d also heard many negative things about those specific shops. I couldn’t find one bad thing about Spencer or his store. His shop will definitely be the one I return to once I’m re-established and ready to start a collection for my son when he gets older. Thanks again, Spencer — it was an absolute pleasure doing business with you!