Muller Rare Coins & Fine Jewelry logo

Muller Rare Coins & Fine Jewelry

ID: 6361Jewelry Store372 mi from youHamburg, PA 19526+1 (610) 562-7687

For over 50 years, Muller Rare Coins & Fine Jewelry has been one of the largest buyers and sellers of rare coins, precious metals, and fine jewelry in the Northeast Region, serving the Hamburg, PA area with an extensive inventory of numismatics, diamonds, and estate pieces. This trusted coin dealer specializes in rare coins,.9999% fine silver bullion, loose diamonds, and engagement rings, built on a foundation of fair pricing and quality products.…

4.5(138 reviews)
Share this Dealer

About Muller Rare Coins & Fine Jewelry

For over 50 years, Muller Rare Coins & Fine Jewelry has been one of the largest buyers and sellers of rare coins, precious metals, and fine jewelry in the Northeast Region, serving the Hamburg, PA area with an extensive inventory of numismatics, diamonds, and estate pieces. This trusted coin dealer specializes in rare coins,.9999% fine silver bullion, loose diamonds, and engagement rings, built on a foundation of fair pricing and quality products. Whether you're looking to buy or sell coins, jewelry, or precious metals, Muller offers the expertise and selection to meet your needs.

Active ListingLast verified: February 27, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review
4.5
★★★★½
9 reviews · 4.5 (129 on Google)
5
6
4
0
3
1
2
0
1
2
Fairy Rose Studio
Fairy Rose StudioGoogle★★★★★
Very helpful and above board.
— Fairy Rose Studio, Jan 2026
swoosh1433
swoosh1433Google★☆☆☆☆
Silver hits high prices and this place closes its door. Refuses to buy.
— swoosh1433, Jan 2026
Steve Smith
Steve SmithGoogle★★★☆☆
I would give 5 stars if only I was able to only ever deal with the man that works there. (I wish I would have gotten his name ) My first experience there was great, he was very straight forward and confident in what he was telling me. He offered me a very fair price and took his time . The second time I was not impressed. The lady who works there was the employee I had dealt with. Her people skills were terrible , she was rude and completely low balled me. I questioned the offer she made and she nervously changed it to a few $ more per coin.. she didn’t look at them at all ,just threw them on the scale . I told here that a few were pretty good ones and she said. “It’s not worth it with this price of silver “ and then proceeded to go about her business. I m debating if I will return there again in fear she will be the lady who waits on me .
— Steve Smith, Feb 2026
Joe Zielinski
Joe ZielinskiGoogle★★★★★
First time there, the staff was very polite and knowledgeable. They paid more than anyone I checked with They also gave us good information on the items that they didn't want to purchase. For sure we will go back, no need to go anywhere else. I'm glad we checked the place out. I would recommend to all
— Joe Zielinski, Feb 2026
Karen Walter Sahaydak
Karen Walter SahaydakGoogle★★★★★
It was easy to deal with Muller’s. When we brought in our gold and silver it was exactly as they said it would be worth when we called. We were in and out quickly and got a good deal. Great service too!
— Karen Walter Sahaydak, Jan 2025
Ty Kern
Ty KernGoogle★★★★★
Aaron Muller, the ceo, helped me pick out an engagement ring and wedding band. I couldn’t have asked for a better experience. Wasn’t rushed or pressured during the process and he was very knowledgeable on the business and product(s). Stop by and check the shop out. Great Prices and great selections. He has something for everyone and every budget.
— Ty Kern, Dec 2024
James Grodon
James GrodonGoogle★★★★★
I have been driving a hour to get here, for years, because of honest straight forwardness of this place. There is no hiding your silver under a writing pad, which happened to me at a different dealer. Or changing the agreements when silver , I had ordered, arrived Which also happened to me at another dealer. Every time at this dealer, Muller, honest, straight, as expected, an example of how other dealers should conduct business
— James Grodon, May 2025
Arnold Jacobs
Arnold JacobsGoogle★★★★★
I think they are fair with their prices. Pepole go on line look at prices and show up thinking they are going to get that price. good lock they need to make money to .
— Arnold Jacobs, Jan 2026
rich zakutney
rich zakutneyGoogle★☆☆☆☆
If you want them to weight your gold in Pennyweights then, offer you significantly less then what it weighs in grams then, I would say go for it. Just look around you will find much better offers.
— rich zakutney, Nov 2025

Write a Review

You must be logged in to leave a review.

Log In to Review