Dempsey & Baxter is a trusted coin dealer in Erie, PA offering expert buying and selling of rare coins, collectible currency, and numismatic treasures. With a passion for numismatics and extensive knowledge of precious metals, the shop serves collectors and investors seeking authentic coins and professional appraisals. Whether you're building a collection or liquidating your holdings, Dempsey & Baxter provides reliable service and fair market values.
Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.
0
Very nice people
Warm welcoming store , with highest quality repair and jewelry. Highly recommend . Very extensive collection and kind knowledgeable employees
Very friendly personality from the woman who greated me as soon as I walked in the door. Thank you for making me feel welcome.
Emily was great! She was very helpful and friendly! All the items I purchased were in excellent condition!
I took several items to sell and the one that stands out the most was a ring the woman tried to buy it for 100 it's worth 550 and sell your gold online offered me 454 so I think it's fair to say that they do indeed try to take advantage of people that don't know what they have. There were several pieces of sterling including a Tiffany clip and an Italian horn that were worth at least 100 each and I had a few other things that she weighed All together and gave me 39.85 for I didn't sell the rings I took and the only reason I sold what I did was to be courteous for the time she spent going through my items. Emily was nice but I don't think it was genuine however the reason I gave a two was because there was a nice man who spoke to me and showed me a really old penny he just purchased while I waited for her to check a couple things. She wrote out a detailed list of everything but didn't write the weight of any of the things so I can't show that but I know I did not get fair price I was the Bigger person sold the things I didn't really care about just so she didn't waste all her time I just wanted to share with everyone that if you don't know what you have do not take it here they have 4.8 stars probably half are people they know personally and why only179 reviews if you have been in business for 60 years I would think there would be a lot more reviews. I definitely will not be going back here to sell any of my stuff I'll stick to sellyourgold online they are extremely fair and it's legit I have sold a few things and they give the best price around.
Dempsey & Baxter is my go to for gifts. I always experience outstanding service. Jeff has been a really big help my last few visits. I tell him what I’m looking for and he gets things narrowed down, making for an easy decision. The whole crew at Dempsey & Baxter is first class. I highly recommend them.
Brian was amazing in absolutely every way—knowledgeable, caring, patient, kind, and genuinely invested in helping us. And Mike was just as on point! We were selling coins that had been passed down through the family, and my mom is a total detail-lover who needs to know everything. Brian and Mike handled it perfectly. Their sense of humor made the whole process fun, comfortable, and truly enjoyable. Can't wait to go back!
Mike was so personable, friendly, helpful, honest and kind, I can’t say enough about him. We will definitely be back. Also, we have to compliment Lesley. She is awesome and so knowledgeable …she always greets us and remembers us every time we come in. Love love love coming into your store!
You must be logged in to leave a review.
Log In to Review