🏪

Colonial Coin and Jewelers

ID: 3302Jewelry Store126 mi from youCleveland, OH 44115+1 (216) 526-8613

Founded in 1921, Colonial Coin and Jewelers is Cleveland's premier destination for buying and selling coins, stamps, precious metals, and jewelry, with over 100 years of trusted service as a fourth-generation family-owned business. Located inside the historic 5th Street Arcade Building at 530 Prospect Ave, this coin dealer specializes in numismatics, gold and silver appraisals, and serves as Cleveland's top buyer, seller, and appraiser for rare coins and collectibles.

4.8(201 reviews)
Share this Dealer

About Colonial Coin and Jewelers

Founded in 1921, Colonial Coin and Jewelers is Cleveland's premier destination for buying and selling coins, stamps, precious metals, and jewelry, with over 100 years of trusted service as a fourth-generation family-owned business. Located inside the historic 5th Street Arcade Building at 530 Prospect Ave, this coin dealer specializes in numismatics, gold and silver appraisals, and serves as Cleveland's top buyer, seller, and appraiser for rare coins and collectibles.

Active ListingLast verified: February 26, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review
4.8
★★★★☆
9 reviews · 4.8 (192 on Google)
5
8
4
0
3
1
2
0
1
0
Stephen Wojtila
Stephen WojtilaGoogle★★★★★
Quick service and affordable watch battery replacement! Definitely recommend!
— Stephen Wojtila, Jan 2026
Daniel Nunney
Daniel NunneyGoogle★★★★★
Best pricing and easy to work with!
— Daniel Nunney, Jan 2026
Kris Riley
Kris RileyGoogle★★★☆☆
3 star review
— Kris Riley, Feb 2026
George Marinakis
George MarinakisGoogle★★★★★
I highly recommend Colonial Coin. Gary and Justin are extremely knowledgeable and easy to work with. I have dealt with many coin dealers over the years and they are dealers I trust the most.
— George Marinakis, Feb 2026
Matt Daugherty
Matt DaughertyGoogle★★★★★
I am the Wardrobe Supervisor for a National Touring Company of " The Notebook" I had a watch the broke on stage and I took to the shop. They were extremely helpful and had my piece fixed and on my way in just a few moments. Highly recommend them !!
— Matt Daugherty, Sep 2025
Gerrij Grant
Gerrij GrantGoogle★★★★★
Very professional and friendly...went out the way to adjust my husband watch also polished and got new battery ❤️
— Gerrij Grant, Aug 2025
Craig Brown
Craig BrownGoogle★★★★★
I have been going here for several years and the staff is very helpful for watches and jewelry. They are very fair and timely with their service. I have recommended them to several of the employees at my firm.
— Craig Brown, Dec 2025
M O
M OGoogle★★★★★
Always a pleasure to do business here. Great selection, great prices and amazing insights to add to your collection. Whenever I'm in town this is one of my first stops. Mike from Georgia.
— M O, Dec 2025
A Michaele
A MichaeleGoogle★★★★★
Shop was lovely and charming. Selection was amazing and Gary was so kind and helpful. It’s an honest family run business and they will give a good price for coin/silver. Will definitely return for my next jewelry purchase.
— A Michaele, Jan 2026

Write a Review

You must be logged in to leave a review.

Log In to Review