About Coin Shop Cleveland
Come See Us at Our New Location! 500 West Aurora Road, Suite 130. Sagamore Hills, OH 44067 · Call: 216-476-1556 · Formerly Located at · State Licensed Precious
🏪
Coin Shop Cleveland
Coin Shop Cleveland is a coin dealer in Sagamore Hills, Ohio, listed in the US Coin Shows numismatic directory. Contact them at +1 (216) 476-1556. Browse their specialties, show attendance, and reviews below. Find more coin dealers in Ohio and upcoming coin shows near Sagamore Hills in our directory.
4.2(79 reviews)
Active ListingLast verified: February 26, 2026
Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.
0Reviews & Ratings
Write a Review4.2
★★★★☆
7 reviews · 4.1 (72 on Google)
5★
7
4★
0
3★
0
2★
0
1★
0
Joseph DavisGoogle★★★★★
Sure great guy to work with! Always fair!!!— Joseph Davis, Nov 2025
Mr B.Google★★★★★
Professional team. Paying top $$ for your silver bullions!— Mr B., Dec 2025
Jesse DeSotoGoogle★★★★★
I stopped by to buy some silver and I was greeted by Mike who later introduced me to Matt. They sold me 10 ounces slightly cheaper than I could have had it delivered online even with free shipping so I was happy and they had a decent selection to choose from as well. I was in and out quickly on my way to work and I look forward to future business.— Jesse DeSoto, Dec 2021
Lilian CGoogle★★★★★
Mike at Coin Shop was very professional and made me a very good offer on my gold jewelry. Just prior to coming there, I went to Wills Jewelry, where they offer "the best pricing". WILLS does NOT have the best pricing. The BEST pricing is AT THE COIN SHOP. You compare and see.— Lilian C, May 2025
Ohio DJ Pros LLCGoogle★★★★★
These gentleman are incredible. I’ve been dealing with them on and off since they had the shop in Westpark. Regardless if you’re buying or selling, you can be sure you’ll get the best price!!!— Ohio DJ Pros LLC, Jan 2026
Logan EisenhartGoogle★★★★★
Ring door bell to get in, door is locked. Good experience. Nice selection. Fair prices for buying and selling. Felt safe. Nice staff.— Logan Eisenhart, Feb 2026
Patrick GoldbergGoogle★★★★★
Outstanding experience. I always shied away from visiting local coin shops due to a bad experience in Akron with a ton of haggling. This was local and overall I'd highly recommend! Came in after ringing the doorbell(good to see a LCS have one of these!) And absolutely no haggling no BS. They got their spot price off of kitco like professionals and paid what they said they would over the phone. Great selection I'll be back hopefully soon!— Patrick Goldberg, Feb 2026
Write a Review
You must be logged in to leave a review.
Log In to Review