🏪

American Coin & Collectibles

ID: 3295Store5 mi from youColumbus, OH 43227+1 (614) 231-1008

This Columbus, OH coin dealer specializes in buying and selling coins, rare numismatics, and precious metals to collectors and investors alike. American Coin & Collectibles offers expert appraisals and a curated selection of vintage and modern coins to meet the needs of both seasoned numismatists and newcomers. Whether you're looking to expand your collection or liquidate precious metals, this trusted dealer provides professional service and competitive pricing.

4.3(71 reviews)
Share this Dealer

About American Coin & Collectibles

This Columbus, OH coin dealer specializes in buying and selling coins, rare numismatics, and precious metals to collectors and investors alike. American Coin & Collectibles offers expert appraisals and a curated selection of vintage and modern coins to meet the needs of both seasoned numismatists and newcomers. Whether you're looking to expand your collection or liquidate precious metals, this trusted dealer provides professional service and competitive pricing.

Active ListingLast verified: February 26, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review
4.3
★★★★½
8 reviews · 4.3 (63 on Google)
5
6
4
1
3
0
2
0
1
1
Paul Waddy
Paul WaddyGoogle★★★★☆
The customer service was excellent. It was a wonderful experience.
— Paul Waddy, Jan 2026
Ghassan Saleh
Ghassan SalehGoogle★★★★★
Best place to buy gold and silver — hands down. They consistently beat other premiums. Call ahead, ask their price over spot, and see for yourself. Honest, family-owned business with great customer service.
— Ghassan Saleh, Feb 2026
Jon Wagner
Jon WagnerGoogle★★★★★
I found them very pleasant to work with and felt they were extremely fair with their offer. They were up front about their percentage of take on the gold/silver. I will use again!
— Jon Wagner, Feb 2026
Marianne Whitlock
Marianne WhitlockGoogle★★★★★
Reviews sound great so it looks like I'll go check them out. I have some coins that say in COD we trust instead of God.
— Marianne Whitlock, Feb 2026
Roger Sr
Roger SrGoogle★★★★★
Today was my first time using American Coin and it won't be the last. Very fair price and glad I went here. Thank you for an easy transaction
— Roger Sr, Jan 2026
James brake
James brakeGoogle★☆☆☆☆
Called asking about the value of some coins. The first two I knew pretty much weren't worth very much if anything . The guy who answered the phone was extremely rude and short with me. If he would have been patient. He would have known that I have A bunch of ms69 and ms 70 ase coins as well as fifty graded, morgan silver dollars and 15 graded gold coins i was looking to sell or trade. Looks like I will be taking my business elsewhere. Based on my experience, I suggest everyone else does so also.
— James brake, Nov 2025
Julie Devore
Julie DevoreGoogle★★★★★
Zach was quick and easy to work with, I sold him 50 ounces of silver and 3 ounces of gold. He was very knowledgeable and paid me cash. I am glad I went there, very easy to deal with. I look foreword to coming in again and buying more silver for my collection
— Julie Devore, Jan 2026
Bill AAnderson
Bill AAndersonGoogle★★★★★
Honest. Fair. Simple. Sold my sterling silver flatware. I know very little about the market for silver, other than there was some "melt value" for my unused utensils. I weighed my pieces, looked up the current silver spot rate and read that the price dealers pay is typically 80% of the spot rate. I can do the math. After calling a couple of places and was quoted 50% to 62% of spot rate, I called ACC. I gave them my weight, after a few questions and calculations I got an estimate that was very close to what my limited understanding came to. So, I went to the shop to close a deal. The owner remembered our conversation. He weighed my pieces within a fraction of an ounce of what my weighing showed. I was expecting a variety of "yeah, buts..." before getting a price. Nope. The price I was quoted over the phone was what I was paid. Could not be more pleased with how honest, fair and simple the whole process was. I have zero reservations recommending ACC.
— Bill AAnderson, Dec 2025

Write a Review

You must be logged in to leave a review.

Log In to Review