Xtra Change of Mahopac, Inc. (buy•sell•trade)

5 star review

Great shop the owner is friendly and knowledgeable. They have a great selection and are always fair on prices no matter if your buying or selling. I have been there multiple times and will continue to go back!!!!!!

Great Store , Great Staff !! Thank You

Such nice people such nice items. These two are amongst the most pleasant guys i've dealt with. Definitely recommend!

4 star review

I love my Louis Vuitton overnight bag. It was in such great condition and at a fraction of the retail price. If you like designer purses, I highly recommend Xtra Change in Mahopac.

A hidden gem with top-notch service and unbeatable prices. You will be greeted with a warm and friendly welcome in the store. Perfect spot for gift hunters and anyone who appreciates friendly, old-school service. You will always be sent off with a “God Bless you” before leaving.

This shop is mighty! As a toy collector, I always walk away with awesome finds 😎. He also has a wide range of unique treasures such as trading cards, tools, and jewelry. There are very few shops like this in the area. The owner Louie is an amazing guy and loves The LORD. If you love the thrill of the hunt (of collectibles), and the support of small businesses, show XTRA CHANGE some love ❤️

XTRA CHANGE in Mahopac is an absolute treasure trove! Louie is a standout — always helpful, genuine, and welcoming. His friendly vibe turns every visit into something special. The shop is filled with unexpected gems that you’ll want to explore and take home. It’s the kind of place where browsing becomes an experience — and yes, you’ll probably spend more than you planned! If you're looking for a welcoming spot with great service, fair deals, and a collection of cool treasures, this is it. Highly recommend dropping in — it’s a visit you’ll enjoy every time.

Louie is one of the most honest, business men I know. I have been shopping and doing business at his establishments from day1. My kids love going in and looking for a hidden treasure, or something you’ve been looking all over for and boom there it is , casually sitting on a shelf, I 99.9% leave empty handed…or he’s alaways giving the kids something as a kind gesture … I would recommend this business and Louie to anyone ..friends and family alike. A good local business that everyone should support! All the best!