Whitman Coin & Jewelry, Inc. logo

Whitman Coin & Jewelry, Inc.

ID: 889Jewelry Store508 mi from youMelville, NY 11747+1 (631) 673-0111

Whitman Coin & Jewelry is a family-owned coin dealer in Melville, NY with over 50 years of experience as one of the largest bullion dealers on Long Island, buying and selling rare coins and precious metals including gold, silver, and platinum. Beyond numismatics, this multi-faceted business offers expert jewelry sales and repairs, diamond engagement rings, and appraisals from a certified gemologist on staff. Known for their excellent reputation and integrity, Whitman Coin…

4.6(30 reviews)
Share this Dealer

About Whitman Coin & Jewelry, Inc.

Whitman Coin & Jewelry is a family-owned coin dealer in Melville, NY with over 50 years of experience as one of the largest bullion dealers on Long Island, buying and selling rare coins and precious metals including gold, silver, and platinum. Beyond numismatics, this multi-faceted business offers expert jewelry sales and repairs, diamond engagement rings, and appraisals from a certified gemologist on staff. Known for their excellent reputation and integrity, Whitman Coin & Jewelry specializes in both investment-grade coins and competitive collateral loans for unwanted jewelry.

Active ListingLast verified: February 26, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review
4.6
★★★★½
8 reviews · 4.5 (22 on Google)
5
7
4
1
3
0
2
0
1
0
Larry Fischer
Larry FischerGoogle★★★★★
Owner was polite and extremely helpful highly recommended
— Larry Fischer, Sep 2024
Peter XU
Peter XUGoogle★★★★★
What a wonderful place to buy coins! Nice people! Will be back again! Bought a lot of silver!!!
— Peter XU, Oct 2024
Tony Ingle
Tony IngleGoogle★★★★★
Great service
— Tony Ingle, Jan 2026
valerie kole
valerie koleGoogle★★★★☆
I find it surprising that someone called the staff snooty. I have never met a more lovely group of people working in one store. I came in to sell jewelry and was offered more there than in the 4 other stores that I had price checked. I ended up buying a beautiful necklace with the money that I received from the sale of my jewelry. Their selection is unbelievable and, again, to contradict the previous review, nothing is old or crappy.I would recommend this store without hesitation!!! Thanks for a great experience!
— valerie kole, Mar 2013
Nicole Masiello
Nicole MasielloGoogle★★★★★
My family has been going to Whitman's for over 30 years. Love everyone working there. I always feel comfortable that I am getting a reasonable price and good quality jewelry.
— Nicole Masiello, Mar 2024
Jessica Hill
Jessica HillGoogle★★★★★
Husband and I bought our wedding rings there last year and they were lovely to work with. There were a few issues with my husband's ring size but they jumped through hoops to make sure we had it the day before we left for our destination wedding. We went back for our first anniversary and I had something in mind but after Liz showed me a bunch of other options I went with something else that I like even more. Would def recommend!
— Jessica Hill, Aug 2022
Samantha & Kelly LoCascio
Samantha & Kelly LoCascioGoogle★★★★★
Walked in and was greeted by a very friendly and professional staff! We wanted to have a watch sized and they did it on the spot within a few minutes we were out the door! Very satisfied and will be back :).
— Samantha & Kelly LoCascio, Nov 2025
Arthur Spangel
Arthur SpangelGoogle★★★★★
A very well managed business. Well staffed, clean, and organized. David met with me privately and reviewed my coins. He gave me a fair offer which I accepted. I would definitely go back here in the future.
— Arthur Spangel, Feb 2026

Write a Review

You must be logged in to leave a review.

Log In to Review