🏪

Webster Jewelry and Coin Exchange

ID: 5940Jewelry Store365 mi from youWebster, NY 14580+1 (585) 755-8358

Webster Jewelry and Coin Exchange is a family-owned coin dealer with over 30 years of experience buying and selling coins, precious metals, and collectibles in Webster, NY. Located at 159 West Main Street, they specialize in US and foreign coins, gold, silver bullion, jewelry, sterling flatware, and antiques, built on a foundation of trust, honesty, and integrity. Whether you're looking to sell scrap gold, rare coins, or vintage items, their expert team…

4.9(86 reviews)
Share this Dealer

About Webster Jewelry and Coin Exchange

Webster Jewelry and Coin Exchange is a family-owned coin dealer with over 30 years of experience buying and selling coins, precious metals, and collectibles in Webster, NY. Located at 159 West Main Street, they specialize in US and foreign coins, gold, silver bullion, jewelry, sterling flatware, and antiques, built on a foundation of trust, honesty, and integrity. Whether you're looking to sell scrap gold, rare coins, or vintage items, their expert team provides fair valuations for items in any condition.

Active ListingLast verified: February 27, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review
4.9
★★★★☆
6 reviews · 4.9 (80 on Google)
5
6
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
0
Suzy A
Suzy AGoogle★★★★★
I am so thankful that all of the positive reviews led me here! I've contemplated for so long about whether or not to sell my jewelry that I no longer wear. I never felt like I could fully trust anyone! Well, let me tell you - from the moment I walked in, I knew I'd come to the right place. Greg explained how the process works and he made me feel confident and comfortable throughout the entire process and his personality is outstanding! This is the 100% the place you'll want to go!!!
— Suzy A, Jan 2026
Kris McGee
Kris McGeeGoogle★★★★★
Friendly owners, very fair pricing on buying and selling. very Knowledgeable and a good atmosphere. Love going there!
— Kris McGee, Dec 2025
Phil Garrod
Phil GarrodGoogle★★★★★
Great gold and silver exchange, buy or sell. Owners Frank and Greg will take good care of you. Very personable and professional.
— Phil Garrod, Dec 2025
John Dudkiewicz
John DudkiewiczGoogle★★★★★
No matter if your looking to sell or to buy, Frank and Greg are as honest and trustworthy as they come. It's the only place I go to buy or sell Gold , silver or coins and currency. Thanks guys your the best!!!
— John Dudkiewicz, Jan 2026
mikeysmom87
mikeysmom87Google★★★★★
The staff are friendly and knowledgeable. Good selection of coins, jewelry, Mackenzie Child's and vintage toys. Very fair prices
— mikeysmom87, Jan 2026
Thomas Robinson
Thomas RobinsonGoogle★★★★★
A fun little neighborhood shop, definitely worth stopping by to check out. Part coin shop, part jewler and part antique shop, they have so many curiosities. I've been buying from these two brothers for years, and they've always been good to me. Fair prices and they will take time to answer your questions and provide a little advice. If you are out and about on a weekend take a little peek inside, you'll be happy you did.
— Thomas Robinson, Jan 2026

Write a Review

You must be logged in to leave a review.

Log In to Review