🏪

The Gold Exchange #1 Gold Buyer in WNY. Highest prices paid!

ID: 5921Jewelry Store302 mi from youTonawanda, NY 14150+1 (716) 998-3990

The Gold Exchange is your trusted coin dealer in Tonawanda, NY, offering the highest prices paid for gold, silver, and rare coins. This premier precious metals buyer specializes in numismatics and provides expert appraisals whether you're looking to buy and sell coins or liquidate your collection. As Western New York's #1 gold buyer, they deliver competitive pricing and professional service for all your coin and precious metals needs.

4.8(123 reviews)
Share this Dealer

About The Gold Exchange #1 Gold Buyer in WNY. Highest prices paid!

The Gold Exchange is your trusted coin dealer in Tonawanda, NY, offering the highest prices paid for gold, silver, and rare coins. This premier precious metals buyer specializes in numismatics and provides expert appraisals whether you're looking to buy and sell coins or liquidate your collection. As Western New York's #1 gold buyer, they deliver competitive pricing and professional service for all your coin and precious metals needs.

Active ListingLast verified: February 26, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review
4.8
★★★★☆
7 reviews · 4.8 (116 on Google)
5
6
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
1
Michael Martin
Michael MartinGoogle★★★★★
Super friendly and definetly honest. I had no issues durring my vist.
— Michael Martin, Feb 2026
Angel Palma
Angel PalmaGoogle★☆☆☆☆
Will try to lie to you to get a better deal. Better off going somewhere else.
— Angel Palma, Feb 2026
raj kolan
raj kolanGoogle★★★★★
Tommy and heather are the sweetest people you can ever meet and work with and are the best in town both with the prices. Go to them and you won’t be disappointed or even surprised with their prices.
— raj kolan, Dec 2025
Britt Diehl
Britt DiehlGoogle★★★★★
I stopped into Gold Exchange to find some fine estate jewelry after researching the establishment online. The gentleman working, who I assume is one of the owners, was attentive and helpful. Many customers came in while I was there and all of them seemed to have a good relationship with the owner which was nice to see. There was not a large selection of fine jewelry but I did find several items I was interested in. The tagged prices were not in-line with what you can buy the items for today online but it didn't matter much because the owner was more interested in me making reasonable offer. This resulted in me purchasing two of the 4 items I liked and I left extremely pleased with my experience with the owner, the price I paid, and what I purchased. Looking forward to stopping in periodically to see what other jewelry items they have!
— Britt Diehl, Feb 2023
Parker Harris
Parker HarrisGoogle★★★★★
Tommy and Susie are absolutely wonderful to work with! They’re honest, easygoing, and truly pay top dollar for gold and silver. Such a sweet couple who take the time to give great advice and make you feel comfortable throughout the whole process. If you have any jewelry, gold, or silver to sell, definitely bring it to them — they’ll earn your business!
— Parker Harris, Dec 2025
Deb Engler
Deb EnglerGoogle★★★★★
My first experience there was amazing! Met with Susie. Sold some designer wallets and also some gold jewelry to her husband Tommy and Rich. Both gentlemen were fantastic as well. I felt I was given a very fair and honest deal! Better than some other places. Tommy was beyond helpful, at the end he gave me boxes to put the jewelry I didn't sell into them to avoid tangling. Thanks team! I will be back:)
— Deb Engler, Nov 2025
Joseph Vekich
Joseph VekichGoogle★★★★★
Like walking into a family members house, trustworthy, open and honest, and simply a joy to work with. No scams no shady conversation, just upfront honest chats and extremely fair pricing at the buy and the sell. No fees just straight up +/- a bit of spot when dealing. I will be back monthly and take Tommy’s advice as part of my over all financial model.
— Joseph Vekich, Dec 2025

Write a Review

You must be logged in to leave a review.

Log In to Review