Millers Mint Ltd

I highly recommend Miller's Mint. They have solid pricing, and they do great & honest business here. Matt was very diligent and knowledgeable, and he truly took his time when we were discussing everything. Definitely will do future business with them.

Miller's Mint is an outstanding establishment with an extensive selection of high quality items and amazing customer service! They are a pleasure to do business with every single time. Highly recommend!

Went to Miller's Mint Saturday morning ,got there when they opened and I was met by a super friendly staff that was not only highly knowledgeable but treated me like family and this was my first time doing buisness with them. They paid me very fair prices for my precious metals that I sold them. I honestly can say this place is truly a great buisness and I will be doing buisness with them again in the near future. I highly recommend Miller's Mint to anyone looking to unload there collections or to buy. They have a huge inventory and you can literally spend days there and not see everything. There prices are fair and the staff there will treat you right. You too will be very pleased with your experience with them whether your buying or selling.

I finally stopped in after passing many times. I had a few coins to test the waters and possibly sell. I dealt primarily with Matt but the overall staff presence was very welcoming. Honestly, I can't really say the payout for the items sold was necessarily higher than other shops(I was pleased with the outcome). But, I can say the transactions are effortless and pressure free. An added bonus is Miller's Mint is more open to a wider range of items they purchase. I didn't really focus on inventory as I was not looking to purchase anything at the time. I have no doubts about returning. Sometimes, regardless of negative or positive reviews, it's best to experience yourself and form your own opinion.

I had an absolutely outstanding experience at Miller’s in Patchogue. I came in with a mixed collection of coins, silver, and paper money, not really knowing what I had or what it was worth. I had done some research beforehand and had a rough estimate in mind but, they completely exceeded my expectations. From the moment I walked in, the staff was incredibly professional, patient, and knowledgeable. They took the time to go through every single piece with me, explaining what each item was, what to look for, and how the value was determined. There was zero pressure—just honest, transparent evaluation. What really impressed me was their expertise. I had a few items I thought might be silver, and they immediately identified them as fake just by the weight and sound. Then they went a step further and tested them right in front of me to show exactly why they weren’t real. That level of honesty and willingness to educate is rare. They made the entire process comfortable and actually enjoyable, which I never expected walking into a coin shop. In the end, I received an offer that far exceeded what I thought I’d get, and I left feeling confident I was treated fairly. If you have coins, silver, or collectibles and want a place that is honest, knowledgeable, and genuinely helpful, I can’t recommend Miller’s enough. I wouldn’t go anywhere else.😍

1st time in this Shop today & had a great experience shop was busy, and staff was very attentive and knowledgeable, I will be back for my next coin / bullion purchase

Great, honest, fast appraisal of my coins, very knowledgeable and pleasant to deal with....would highly recommend anyone to do business with them

Great place to sell your coins Fast service

Harry is fantastic, the team is wonderful. I am very lucky to fine them.

Had an absolutely wonderful experience here! The staff is extremely knowledgeable and welcoming. My brother and I had an estate box from our late father that had numerous kinds of coins and metals and the entire process was quick and painless. It made parting with a piece of our dad a lot easier and we felt like we were in great hands the entire time. I could not recommend this place more! Definitely give them a chance to make you an offer on your valuables or if you’re in the market to purchase, stop in to look at their large collection of items for sale. You won’t be disappointed :)

Honest, transparent, and fair. Miller’s made the entire process easy and stress-free, and I was very happy with the payout. Highly recommend.

I want to Thanks! the Staff, for the Wonderful Service this Morning, I visit the Store looking for some Interesting Rare Items, that I Order, and they had all of them, plus amazing Prices. Yes and I got some Extras too, I recommend" for Every one and I being going there for 25 Years, Always good, Thanks' Have a Great Day.

This place is awesome! I’ve come in here numerous times and Matt has always treated me good and gave me the maximum amount of money for my Items! HIGHLY reccomend this place. Thanks Millers Mint!

My father was a long time customer and always spoke highly of Millers Mint. This was my first time visiting. The person who helped me obviously knew what they were talking about. He was, polite and quick to value and pay for the few coins I had, and I left happy. I hope next time I can speak to someone more formally/more time about the rest of my dad's collection. Looking foward to coming back!