Everything Under the Sun

Name: Everything Under the Sun
Address: 386 Rugar Street, Plattsburgh, NY, 12901, US
Telephone: +1 (518) 420-4837
Rating: 3.7

ID: 6918Clothing Store584 mi from youPlattsburgh, NY 12901 +1 (518) 420-4837

Located in Plattsburgh, NY, Everything Under the Sun is a full-service coin dealer specializing in numismatics, collectibles, jewelry, and more, serving Clinton and Essex Counties, Vermont, and Montreal. They offer free coin appraisals available Sundays through Tuesdays, budget-friendly pricing, and a convenient one-month layaway policy for customers. Whether you're looking to buy, sell, or appraise coins, this trusted local coin shop provides expert service and competitive rates.

3.5(35 reviews)

Share this Dealer

About Everything Under the Sun

Active ListingLast verified: February 27, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

Official Source →Report a correction

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review

3.5

★★★½☆

7 reviews · 3.5 (28 on Google)

5★

4★

3★

2★

1★

Elena MitchellGoogle★☆☆☆☆Mar 2024

Owners daughter had the shop closed with open signs and lights off when owner was on vacation. Obviously not a professional setting, definitely will never sell there.

— Elena Mitchell, Mar 2024

Dan BrownGoogle★★★★★Nov 2024

Lots of stuff to bring you down memory lane. And the people are very nice and helpful as well.

— Dan Brown, Nov 2024

Devin SmithGoogle★★★★☆Dec 2023

Wow! I was t expecting to see the amazing collection of Sci-Fi memorabilia. Star Wars, Star Trek…. And the old Video Game consoles and games were a very impressive collection to behold. I found a 1930’s GE radio in need of some tender lovin’ care and took it home! If you’re in Plattsburgh and you love Sci-Fi and gaming, you’ve got to see this place. This is more of a guy’s memorabilia store.

— Devin Smith, Dec 2023

View on Google

Jason GodfroyGoogle★★★★★Aug 2025

Great assortment of collectibles, negotiable prices...awesome location. It's the best thrift shop in town.

— Jason Godfroy, Aug 2025

View on Google

Mad Mads (Mad Mads Music)Google★★☆☆☆Dec 2025

Amazing selection of items, terribly overpriced. Definitely Scalpers or resellers where they charge a ton. Be warned.

— Mad Mads (Mad Mads Music), Dec 2025

View on Google

Yan O'CainGoogle★★★★☆Dec 2023

A great place to find vintage toys and video games! Books, jewelry, antics, lots of items. Staff is always welcoming.

— Yan O'Cain, Dec 2023

View on Google

ferd burphelGoogle★★★★★Feb 2026

10 out of 10. Very nice family that run a needed local business. From collectible christmas shopping to silver/gold stacking this is where I have started for the last 10 years. The prices are incredibly reasonable and I feel good giving my hard earned money to this family business. Im 47 years in a 4 generation family business.....they have my referral! Please support local business 🍻

— ferd burphel, Feb 2026

View on Google