Since 1954, this family-owned coin dealer in Waretown, NJ has been serving numismatists and collectors with expert knowledge spanning nearly 45 years of experience in coins and stamps. Owner Matt specializes in buying and selling coins, offering the expertise of a dedicated philatelist and numismatist at their Route 9 location. Visit Waretown Coin & Stamp Wednesday through Saturday for quality service rooted in a passionate legacy of numismatics.
Since 1954, this family-owned coin dealer in Waretown, NJ has been serving numismatists and collectors with expert knowledge spanning nearly 45 years of experience in coins and stamps. Owner Matt specializes in buying and selling coins, offering the expertise of a dedicated philatelist and numismatist at their Route 9 location. Visit Waretown Coin & Stamp Wednesday through Saturday for quality service rooted in a passionate legacy of numismatics.
Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.
0
Always a pleasure to work with the staff! They’re great! They have many items for sale and are very helpful and knowledgeable is telling you the value or appraising your items!— Kevin Ellul, Nov 2025
Bonnie knows her stuff. Very knowledgeable and honest.— P Carlisle, Nov 2025
5 star review— Donna Hernandez, Dec 2025
Bonnie and Nick came to our home to help us appraise coins and jewelry. They were so helpful and fair. The entire process was seamless. Would highly recommend this company.— Carol Ann Donchin, Sep 2025
They are Very fair and Honest people I have dealt with Bonnie several times and Nick and way back with the two brothers they are all up front honest and always gave me the best deal possible. Thanks— Peter, Jan 2026
My husband and I recently sold some gold here and I have to say the level of service we received from Bonnie was top notch. Bonnie was super helpful and knowledgeable. We couldn’t have been more pleased with our experience here and will for sure be back!— Athena Polyviou, Nov 2025
I visited several places to get quotes for some gold I wanted to sell, and Waretown Stamp and Coin was by far the best experience. The team was kind, honest, and never pushy. I truly felt they had my best interests at heart. I highly recommend them. Also, Bonnie was an absolute pleasure to work with!— Anthony Lugo, Nov 2025
We had a great experience here. Rebecca and Bonnie are awesome and very knowledgeable. Prices are posted so you can know and understand what to expect. It was me and my mom and we sold some gold and sterling silver. With such great prices and great service we went back a week later with more jewelry. This is definitely our go to place now.— Palmer Palmer, Sep 2025
You must be logged in to leave a review.
Log In to Review
