Monmouth Stamp & Coin Shop

5 star review

4 star review

Insanely high premiums

I think I got a fair price and appraisal for some relatively low value coins. Stamps I knew were worthless. Had none of the issues described in reviews

This is one of the worst places to go to either buy or sell any coins or paper money. The proprietor is an older gentelman...and I use that term gentleman, just to be kind...he will literally give you nothing for your items and sell them at top figures. The young man I met the other day said "We have been here for 70 years!" Rest assured my fellow collectors, these folks have been "dishonest" for 70 years. If you buy or sell with this charlatin...you deserve to be taken. Buyer and seller, beware!

I have never been so disappointed after leaving a coin shop. Staff was not helpful, and the worst part was they don’t even honor their own prices listed. They claim that since the metals market it always moving thing have to be priced daily. This would be true for silver and gold, as well as junk silver, but on numismatics this is disgusting behavior. They also refused to provide the price guide that they used to value their coins, and their “old” prices are already over retail prices. Save your time and your gas and go somewhere else.

The worst shop. They have 10-12% premiums over the spot price.

Have been there on a four occasions and have always found great stuff to help build older Topps Baseball Card sets. The prices were fair and even fantastic. 02/20/2025 update. Never again will I go into this business. After my previous visits and great interactions with the employees, I had the “pleasure” of dealing with this lil fella who had more attitude then stature. Zero people in the business and the indignity of asking to go over a want list was like I told the lil fella I wanted it for free. Total zero sum lil fella who lost a customer in me after this. My previous visits where I spent between $2,500 and $3,000 are over.