🏪

Mike's We Buy Gold & Silver

ID: 5695Service472 mi from youShrewsbury, NJ 07702+1 (732) 768-1197

Mike's We Buy Gold & Silver is a trusted precious metals and coin dealer located at 1175 Broad Street in Shrewsbury, NJ, offering fair cash prices for gold, silver, platinum, diamonds, and watches. Their knowledgeable team tests all items to determine purity and weight, ensuring transparent and professional service that customers consistently praise. Open Monday through Saturday from 10 AM to 6 PM, they're conveniently located across from the Americana Diner on…

4.5(160 reviews)
Share this Dealer

About Mike's We Buy Gold & Silver

Mike's We Buy Gold & Silver is a trusted precious metals and coin dealer located at 1175 Broad Street in Shrewsbury, NJ, offering fair cash prices for gold, silver, platinum, diamonds, and watches. Their knowledgeable team tests all items to determine purity and weight, ensuring transparent and professional service that customers consistently praise. Open Monday through Saturday from 10 AM to 6 PM, they're conveniently located across from the Americana Diner on Route 35 North.

Active ListingLast verified: February 27, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review
4.5
★★★★½
8 reviews · 4.5 (152 on Google)
5
6
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
2
Anna Schneider
Anna SchneiderGoogle★★★★★
Great experience. Easy to deal with. Fair pricing.
— Anna Schneider, Aug 2025
Desirie Johnson
Desirie JohnsonGoogle★★★★★
Welcoming environment.expectaions and offers often meant.
— Desirie Johnson, Aug 2025
Chris Pellegrini
Chris PellegriniGoogle★★★★★
very good experience, professional, quick , very fair price for my gold
— Chris Pellegrini, Dec 2025
Gonzalo Barba
Gonzalo BarbaGoogle★★★★★
After my father-in-law passed away, he left us a collection of gold and silver coins, along with gold jewelry. We had no idea where to start, so we visited a few local shops for estimates. Unfortunately, most places were either rude or just gave us a bulk price without explaining the details. Then we remembered MIKES WE BUY GOLD, a business that has been in the same location for over 50 years. From the moment we walked in, we were treated with kindness and professionalism. The owner’s wife took the time to carefully explain the value of each item and even pointed out which pieces might be worth keeping for the grandchildren. The level of customer service and honesty was unmatched. If you’re considering selling gold or silver, I highly recommend stopping by MIKES WE BUY GOLD first. Their knowledge, transparency, and outstanding service set them apart from the rest. A+++
— Gonzalo Barba, Mar 2025
Brittany Bailly
Brittany BaillyGoogle★☆☆☆☆
Went there for a second time yesterday the lady at the front was very rude thank you so much for being rude to me because I went somewhere else can cashed out over $6500 ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ go to Main Street Gold and Coins in Red Bank Sam is amazing super honest I went here in the summer brought a bunch of stuff and was only paid $800 and I had a good amount of gold I sold God was on my side yesterday went I entered this dump
— Brittany Bailly, Dec 2025
America First
America FirstGoogle★★★★★
Best prices around, Rinat Z and I automatically clicked moments after I walked in the door. She knows the industry well and is cautious to check authenticity of all precious metals. At gold prices skyrocketing over the past few months reaching an all time high $3,400 and counting per ounce vs the prices I paid less than $1,000 per ounce. I enjoyed the profits cashing in 1 of my 10 ounce bullion and meeting Rinat. She’s my go too gold lady!
— America First, Aug 2025
Sharon Hill
Sharon HillGoogle★★★★★
Sending the BIGGEST SHOUT OUT to (Rinat) from Mikes We Buy Silver & Gold. I just left out of her place of business only to be pleased beyond measure‼️Each and Every time I visit with just random pieces of jewelry I have no more use for, she ALWAYS amazes me with how much I get back. I never would of thought. I've been to other places that buy silver & gold but NEVER have I had the same experience. They always offered me less, and that's why I will ALWAYS GIVE MY BUSINESS TO MIKE‼️And to those of you looking for the BEST DEAL, I suggest you choose Mikes as well. Rinat, again THANK YOU🫶🏿. You FREAKIN ROCK‼️
— Sharon Hill, Aug 2025
Erica
EricaGoogle★☆☆☆☆
definitely won't be back! be aware of this place. They will tell you you have 10k gold when you Really have 14k gold or even higher. They also can't tell what real gold is or real silver is. then they will rip you off with there low ball price for gold. They will break off your jewelry. In the pictures the lady broke off the back to my pin and kept the piece to it. In the pictures you can see. It is 14k gold also. Be aware!!!!!!
— Erica, Mar 2024

Write a Review

You must be logged in to leave a review.

Log In to Review