Colonial Valley Coins

Very knowledgeable, honest, and great selection.

Really liked this place . The owner was very helpful and the prices were good. Went to buy silver halfs and they were priced under spot . Will return for sure .

Me and my son have been purchasing metals from rob for about a year now. Always honest straightforward and knowledgeable. Always enjoy our visits.

This is the shop to be at if you want coins that are priced well, and never over graded, the owner is very knowledgeable so expect to come out of here with learning something new every time. Always fair and honest which is key in this business. Highly recommend!

Extremely knowledgeable and fair. I’ve made quite a few purchases here and it was a great experience every time. Great inventory and always gives the best and fairest offer you will find in NJ.

I've enjoyed a few visits to this brick and mortar. I recommend here first before any other location for your buying and selling needs. Competitive prices aswell as knowledge of his craft. Rob is a Professional, Straight and Narrow.