Coin Superstore is a premier coin dealer in Nutley, NJ specializing in buy and sell coins, rare numismatics, and precious metals. With expertise in collectible coins and numismatic investments, they offer competitive pricing and knowledgeable service to both seasoned collectors and newcomers. Visit this trusted Nutley coin dealer for all your numismatic needs and precious metal transactions.
Coin Superstore is a premier coin dealer in Nutley, NJ specializing in buy and sell coins, rare numismatics, and precious metals. With expertise in collectible coins and numismatic investments, they offer competitive pricing and knowledgeable service to both seasoned collectors and newcomers. Visit this trusted Nutley coin dealer for all your numismatic needs and precious metal transactions.
Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.
0
Phenomenal top notch service. Perfect pricing, kind staff, and I was able to have some items analyzed for value so quickly. If you're looking to buy or sell your coins, make Coin Superstore your first (and last) stop!— Jeremy Slagle, Jan 2026
I had a great experience selling my coin collection to Chris the owner. He gave me a great price and I didn't have to haggle. I highly recommend the Coin Super Store in Nutley NJ— mnap142, Jan 2026
5 star review— Javier Perez, Jan 2026
Coin was precisely as advertised and looked better in hand than pictures did justice. Will purchase again in the future.— Tanner Young, Feb 2026
Have been there multiple times to do business and every time had been a pleasure. Mike is awesome to talk to and work with. They are very fair with their offers and a great group of people in general. I’ll continue working with them and would recommend family and friends as well— Ronnie Stiffkowski, Jan 2026
Had a great experience on my first visit. The team are very friendly, professional, and make you feel comfortable. They didn’t try to rush anything, explained all questions I had and were very fair on their offers. I will be going back again and would feel confident in recommending friend and family 100%— Beau R, Jan 2026
Chris runs a top notch place. Loads of variety at very competitive or lower pricing and the shipping was lightning fast. I’ll never buy coins anywhere else moving forward. Great place!!!— Dave Bowen, Sep 2025
We had an awesome time selling our coins to this dealer! Right from the beginning, Chris, the owner, was super honest and open about everything, taking the time to break down the value of each coin for us. There wasn't any pressure, and we really felt like we got a fair deal. It's nice working with someone who genuinely cares about honesty and earning customer trust. We totally recommend this coin dealer to anyone wanting to sell coins!— Antonella L, Dec 2025
Chris runs a great shop - fair and honest. He gave me a very good price for my gold & silver coins & ingots - more than other shops. It was an enjoyable selling experience! His approach is simple - he wants to earn your business and operates on thinner margins to do so. His store is welcoming and secure. I'm so glad I found this place to sell my 'family treasures' instead of listing on Ebay.— Michael Radin, Dec 2025
You must be logged in to leave a review.
Log In to Review
