Caldwell Coins is a trusted coin dealer in Caldwell, NJ, offering a comprehensive selection of rare coins, collectible numismatics, and precious metals. We buy and sell coins of all types, from vintage currency to modern commemoratives, serving both serious collectors and investors throughout the area. Whether you're looking to expand your collection or sell your coins, our knowledgeable team provides expert guidance and fair pricing.
Caldwell Coins is a trusted coin dealer in Caldwell, NJ, offering a comprehensive selection of rare coins, collectible numismatics, and precious metals. We buy and sell coins of all types, from vintage currency to modern commemoratives, serving both serious collectors and investors throughout the area. Whether you're looking to expand your collection or sell your coins, our knowledgeable team provides expert guidance and fair pricing.
Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.
0
1 star review— SCOTT MENEGUS, Dec 2023
Cool shop. Cool coins. Stop in and see.— Joe Grey, May 2024
Refuses to sell. Take your business elsewhere - save your gas, money, and time.— P C, Jun 2025
One of the best coin shops I've ever been Barry is super friendly and fun the store is a little small but it's full of numesmatic treasures.— Alex Harson, Mar 2023
i would give 0 stars if i could. this place is disgusting with garbage everywhere, actual garbage. i stunk like cigarettes so bad i needed to take a shower. don't know how this place is open to the public— Anna Murano, Nov 2024
When you visit Caldwell Coins you are not purchasing coins, but the knowledge and history to achieve the right decision for your collection. The proprietor, Barry Hiben, most importantly will listen, assess, and assist you to assemble a quality collection. I highly recommend Barry to any novice, midrange, and advanced coin collector.— Jerry Bruno, Jan 2022
Barry is the best! My son loves going and getting coins from him because he has a story for each.. We have gone 3x in a 2 month time frame🤣. Barry is a coin historian and tells stories on how these coins were made and what makes them valuable. We always go with a budget and Barry always shows my son the best for $20 and under coins and then he can get a few different t ones. He has a huge selection of coins and paper money; he has it all. He doesn’t care if you buy or just want to stop by and chat about coins. Barry’s is a great place you have to check it out.— Cherise shannon, Jun 2022
Owner was upfront and knowledgeable, very fair price. Also very well educated, will answer any and all questions you have, highly recommend.— brent struble, Sep 2025
You must be logged in to leave a review.
Log In to Review