🏪

Carolina Coins

ID: 2501Store372 mi from youSanford, NC 27330+1 (919) 776-2274

top of page Sell Old or Broken Gold Jewelry, Sterling Silverware, Rare Coins, Diamonds, or a Luxury Watch like Rolex & Tag Heuer at the Best Prices Around! ​ Monday-Thursday 10-4PM Walk-Ins Recommended call before you come in. After 4PM or...

4.9(83 reviews)
Share this Dealer

About Carolina Coins

top of page Sell Old or Broken Gold Jewelry, Sterling Silverware, Rare Coins, Diamonds, or a Luxury Watch like Rolex & Tag Heuer at the Best Prices Around! ​ Monday-Thursday 10-4PM Walk-Ins Recommended call before you come in. After 4PM or...

Active ListingLast verified: February 26, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review
4.9
★★★★☆
9 reviews · 4.9 (74 on Google)
5
9
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
0
B Cass
B CassGoogle★★★★★
Excellent
— B Cass, Sep 2024
Morgan Poole
Morgan PooleGoogle★★★★★
I sold some silver bullion I purchased almost 10 years ago, and his pricing was very fair. And he was also very easy to work with.
— Morgan Poole, Oct 2024
K Connolly
K ConnollyGoogle★★★★★
5 star review
— K Connolly, Mar 2025
Heather Peloquin
Heather PeloquinGoogle★★★★★
5 star review
— Heather Peloquin, Jan 2026
Brian Haynes
Brian HaynesGoogle★★★★★
I went into the store looking for a specific foreign coin, not knowing this was not their business focus. The two employees took the time to listen to what I was looking for. Even though this isn't what they sell, the owner located a bag of foreign coins and spent about 15 minutes looking for the coin I was interested in. In the end, he found one and ending up giving it to me. The coin isn't particularly valuable but the fact that he spent the time to help me is very much appreciated!
— Brian Haynes, Jan 2024
Joy Hackney
Joy HackneyGoogle★★★★★
I went to Carolina Coins to get an appraisal of my dad’s coin collection for his estate. Brad and Matt were very knowledgeable and took time to answer my questions. I felt very comfortable there and enjoyed learning about the value of coins. I returned months later to sell the collection and received a fair price. I would definitely go there for any gold or silver valuation needs in the future!! You can’t trust everyone in this kind of business, but I believe them to be quite trustworthy!
— Joy Hackney, Aug 2022
William Ayala, Sr.
William Ayala, Sr.Google★★★★★
I accompanied my wife in visiting this shop. We had a great experience dealing with Brad and Max. They're very professional, knowledgable, pleasant, honest and friendly. Customer service is obviously important here as the staff is attentive and educational. My wife felt she received a reasonable and fair offer for her items. We definitely recommend this shop if you need to buy or sell gold, silver or coins.
— William Ayala, Sr., Jul 2021
Ted Beach
Ted BeachGoogle★★★★★
Great Find!! This place is an hour away from where I live, but it was sure worth the drive, regardless of the outcome. Staff is professional and straightforward. I was relaxed the entire time, learned some new things and was very happy and satisfied with the offer I received with what I was selling. When I was searching online where to go to sell my stuff, this place came up first, even though I live far away. If the need arises, I will definitely be back here again to do business with them. Great people here. Trustworthy, honest and knowledgeable. A+++++
— Ted Beach, Jan 2021
Chase Ketchel
Chase KetchelGoogle★★★★★
Want to give Matt a shout out for helping verify a few pieces for me. I did call a place closer to me first, but Matt had way more professionalism, understanding of my situation, just did his job and helped me out without hesitation... Will definitely be the first place I call if I have any questions or need to do business with in this industry. Thank you sir.
— Chase Ketchel, Jan 2026

Write a Review

You must be logged in to leave a review.

Log In to Review