Read the Gemini Evaluation of US Coin Shows
The Coin Index South logo

The Coin Index South

ID: 363 Store 167 mi from you Greenwood, IN 46142 +1 (317) 402-3806
4.5 (81 reviews)
Share this Dealer

About The Coin Index South

The Coin Index South is a full-service coin dealer in Greenwood, IN specializing in buying, selling, and appraising coins, bullion, and precious metals including gold, silver, platinum, and palladium. They offer collector coins both raw and certified, U.S. and world proof sets, currency, and popular bullion products like American Eagles, Krugerrands, Maple Leafs, and Philharmonics, with wholesale and retail pricing available. Located at 857 North Madison Avenue, they are a member of the ANA, PCGS, NGC, and other numismatic organizations, providing expert service Tuesday through Saturday.

Imported Listing Last verified: February 26, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review
4.5
★★★★½
8 reviews · 4.5 (73 on Google)
5
7
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
1
John Woodside
John Woodside Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Go here.

Michael Lahne
Michael Lahne Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Best prices you’re gonna find to sell scrap gold!!

robin
robin Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Very efficient and effective coin dealers. I sold silver eagles and they quickly got me a fair offer, 93% spot price. I was in and out in under 5 minutes, this place is great

Braydon Hinderliter
Braydon Hinderliter Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Super communicative and knowledgable, sold some silver and picked up some neat cases

View on Google
B K
B K Google ★☆☆☆☆ 1mo ago

This guy is so geeked up on Adderall or something. I asked for some buffalo nickels he said yeah they start at $.75. I said I’d like to buy some. He starts freaking out that they’re graded and slabs and they’re in cases and blah blah blah didn’t wanna listen to anything I had to say cause he’s so geeked up on Adderall and wanted to talk about what he wanted to talk about not interested in what customers wanna buy at all Also do not try to sell anything I tried to sell them liberty. It was a 65 and they offered me Scrap. They said it was worth six dollars. Please people be aware of the shop.

View on Google
Drew Stevenson
Drew Stevenson Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Friendly with a fair prices. I did way better than the local jewelry shop. They have a device to tell the metal content immediately.

View on Google
Misha Eads
Misha Eads Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

I recently took some coins into The Coin Index and was very pleased with this family owned business. The owner took the time to explain everything to me and answer all my questions. They are very friendly and seem to really enjoy their work. I will definitely be returning and telling all my friends and family about this business

View on Google
Geoff Gojko
Geoff Gojko Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Friendly and knowledgeable with decades of business to prove it. Every time I step into this local coin shop, I feel welcome. They are passionate about coins and patient with you when you are deciding what you plan to purchase. Very fair prices and a great place to get your precious metals at a solid deal. They have high quality items and coin collecting supplies readily available. My favorite LCS in Indianapolis.

View on Google

Write a Review

You must be logged in to leave a review.

Log In to Review