Skip to content
National Coin Shop logo

National Coin Shop

ID: 357Finance1057 mi from youIndianapolis, IN 37215+1 (800) 775-3504

For collectors and sellers throughout central Indiana, National Coin Shop serves as Indianapolis's trusted coin dealer for both buying and selling numismatic treasures. Whether you're looking to purchase specific coins for your collection or sell coins from your existing holdings, this established Indy dealer provides professional service to meet your numismatic needs. National Coin Shop operates as a full-service coin dealer in Indianapolis, IN, offering straightforward transactions for collectors at every level.…Read more

3.9(214 reviews)
Share this Dealer

About National Coin Shop

For collectors and sellers throughout central Indiana, National Coin Shop serves as Indianapolis's trusted coin dealer for both buying and selling numismatic treasures. Whether you're looking to purchase specific coins for your collection or sell coins from your existing holdings, this established Indy dealer provides professional service to meet your numismatic needs. National Coin Shop operates as a full-service coin dealer in Indianapolis, IN, offering straightforward transactions for collectors at every level. Their expertise in the local Indianapolis market makes them a reliable choice for both seasoned numismatists and those new to coin collecting.

Active ListingLast verified:

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0
Advertisement

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review
3.9
8 on this site · 206 on Google
5
4
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
7
BigMT21
BigMT21Google
Almost anybody is better than these guys at gold and silver. They try and push high premium metals to anyone who doesn't know better. They try and use high pressure sales. They REALLY hate it when you point out that they are just salesmen and really know nothing about the market. Beware.
— BigMT21, May 2026
Brandon Bauser
Brandon BauserGoogle
Cancelled my order without explanation after having my funds for weeks. Will not respond to my emails and have not received refund. Recommend purchasing your bullion somewhere like SD Bullion or JM Bullion. Both have always come through for me with no hassle. Never had to talk on the phone with someone to verify my purchase before. I had already decided not to use these guys again after that, so this is icing on the cake. Online sales should be fuss free. Pretty sure the required call is just an attempt to up sell. Unfortunately, I lost money on this transaction, since I sold other items to make this purchase and now prices have moved quite a bit. So, definitely not a trustworthy business if your purchases are price dependent at the time. Kind of feel like the business model here is set up to attract people that don't understand bullion. If you need a "personal advisor/agent" to buy gold or silver, it's not for you. That's just another word for salesman.
— Brandon Bauser, Apr 2026
Carl Carlson
Carl CarlsonGoogle
I would not recommend this company to anyone interested in precious metals. They market aggressively at highly inflated prices compared to other dealers especially for numismatic products like Gold Eagle Proof Sets. My father bought 2 of those sets in 2021 at prices that were over twice the spot price of gold at the time suggesting to him that the collectible nature of these was worth the premium and that they would rapidly increase in value. After he passed, we contacted them about selling the sets back to them. First, they wanted me to provide all kinds of personal info about the estate, death certificate, etc in order to consider making a purchase from us. I had provided all that previously. So, I went to their online chat to seek an offer which was actually less than the spot melt value. At the same time, they advertise the identical product on their web site at almost double the purchase offer they quoted to me. Hard to deal with, very poor value. If you really want to invest in precious metals, go to a more reputable dealer and buy only bullion grade coins or bars, NOT what they call collectibles. NOTE: You will now see their canned response. I did in fact contact them by phone and they said they would get back to me. That never happened. My review stands
— Carl Carlson, Sep 2026
Leon Cornute
Leon CornuteGoogle
They miss quoted the amount of silver I agreed to I ordered 2 kilos they billed me for 7 kilos. Now it looks like the Webb site is down, and so are the phones
— Leon Cornute, Dec 2025
Jason G
Jason GGoogle
1 star review
— Jason G, Jan 2026
Kristine
KristineGoogle
I have held quite a few gold coin sets for many years. I decided to sell a few back 'on consignment'. Per their consignment agreement they withhold 18% of their current advertised price on the website. This is totally false!!! They have held 25%, 23%, and 21% from the first 3 transactions that have been completed on my consignment items. I attempted to find out why and a customer service rep said he would reach out to 'someone' and call me back.....crickets. I will update this review if I get more information or they correct the issue but for now I would advise to stay away from this company.
— Kristine, Feb 2026
Monica Casey
Monica CaseyGoogle
US Gold Bureau is the best gold & silver marketing company with which my husband, Bill, and I have ever worked! They do NOT have a $10,000 minimum purchase requirement, which shows they help the little investor. They also have the most competitive prices. Mrs. Rhonda Henry gave us better customer care and service than personnel in 7 different gold & silver marketing companies with whom we recently spoke. Rhonda offered their "Specials', gave us good clear advice and answered all of our questions. She did not push us to buy anything, which demonstrated her genuine heart-to-help and serve attitude. We appreciate, recognize and recommend US Gold Bureau for their professional company policies and procedures and Mrs. Rhonda Henry for her GREAT customer service.
— Monica Casey, Jul 2025
Steve King
Steve KingGoogle
I had a great experience in both buying and selling precious metals here. I don't remember if I spoke with someone when I bought, but I did sell everything back to them online. Thanks
— Steve King, Jan 2026
Heath Dye
Heath DyeGoogle
These guys get their feelings hurt very easily, especially if you ignore their calls and ask them not to call you back after they repeatedly spam you for days. Honestly, they seem desperate to make a sale... No thanks!
— Heath Dye, Jan 2026
Daniel Slade
Daniel SladeGoogle
I worked with Ron Baxter. Thank you sir for helping I guy who had never bought precious metals. I was set up perfect to be successful in the purchase. Ron helped me set up the perfect program. Ron went over everything and was more than patient.
— Daniel Slade, Dec 2025

Write a Review

You must be logged in to leave a review.

Log In to Review

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is National Coin Shop located?
National Coin Shop is located at 4117 Hillsboro Pike in Indianapolis, IN.
What payment methods does National Coin Shop accept?
National Coin Shop accepts Cash.
What are National Coin Shop's hours?
National Coin Shop's hours are 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM.
Advertisement