🏪

Hero's Emporium

ID: 4872Store167 mi from youCarmel, IN 46032+1 (317) 575-1737

Hero's Emporium is a trusted coin dealer in Carmel, IN specializing in numismatics and rare coins for collectors and investors. We buy and sell coins of all types, from ancient and foreign currency to U.S. commemorative pieces and precious metals. Visit our shop to explore quality numismatic items and receive expert guidance on building your collection.

4.6(121 reviews)
Share this Dealer

About Hero's Emporium

Hero's Emporium is a trusted coin dealer in Carmel, IN specializing in numismatics and rare coins for collectors and investors. We buy and sell coins of all types, from ancient and foreign currency to U.S. commemorative pieces and precious metals. Visit our shop to explore quality numismatic items and receive expert guidance on building your collection.

Active ListingLast verified: February 26, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review
4.6
★★★★½
7 reviews · 4.6 (114 on Google)
5
6
4
1
3
0
2
0
1
0
Jonathan Taylor
Jonathan TaylorGoogle★★★★★
Prices are fantastic on sealed magic the gathering! Really nice owner!
— Jonathan Taylor, Jun 2025
Frank Frydrych
Frank FrydrychGoogle★★★★★
5 star review
— Frank Frydrych, Jul 2025
Katharine Brumback
Katharine BrumbackGoogle★★★★☆
Edit: Rating change from 1 to 4. I was able to get into the store during the weekday and the staff were very helpful! The atmosphere is nice and they have a great selection. Updating my review to reflect the change. My only complaint would be the hours not being the same every time. Other than that, I do suggest coming in to Heroes Emporium! It’s hard for me to give a good review on a store when the days I visit shops are when they seem to have special hours or my experience wasn’t the greatest. Out of the 7 times I have tried to visit this shop in a two year span, 3 times were good. The rest were either I stopped by and they ended up closed or had special hours. During the prerelease of Tarkir (mtg set) I planned on purchasing at least 3 boxes. The hours were listed with a spring break schedule and shortened to only being open for 3 hours. I was shocked. Instead, I drove to another shop 15 minutes away and spent about $200 on product. Last year I started getting into painting and one of their citadel paints was completely dry. It was my fault for not checking the product before leaving the store. I didn’t open and discover the issue until 2 weeks after purchase so I did not make an attempt to return it. I really want to like them, because their location is great and they have potential of bringing in the Carmel/Westfield crowd. For now, I’m favoring driving a little extra further away to other shops for their hours/content/availability.
— Katharine Brumback, Jun 2025
Ally Bright
Ally BrightGoogle★★★★★
Got dice for D&D! Was quick and painless. They’ve got a multitude of board games, figurines, and resources you need for fun! Great place to buy someone a gift who is into lots of basic “nerdy” things. Lots of Star Wars, Star Trek. Had Game of Thrones stuff, LOTR, Rick and Marty, etc. Good hours and kind staff, too! Thanks for the cool dice!
— Ally Bright, Sep 2018
Matthew
MatthewGoogle★★★★★
Great people, good prices and a thriving TCG community. I love this place. My teenage son and I try to get here once a week to play cards with others in the evening. Great place, I hope it never goes away.
— Matthew, Jun 2025
Derek Gibson
Derek GibsonGoogle★★★★★
The store is in a great location, has great products, and prices very comparable (and in many cases better) than what you would find online. They have scheduled events that are great for all ages and it is a very welcoming environment. My kids and I are there every week and look forward to going. Support local businesses!
— Derek Gibson, Mar 2025
David Nance
David NanceGoogle★★★★★
Great shop! The owner is a great guy, and some really great folks show up to commander nights. I'm looking forward to the reopening on the 13th of Feb!
— David Nance, Feb 2026

Write a Review

You must be logged in to leave a review.

Log In to Review