Greencastle Coins is a specialized coin dealer in Greencastle, IN that buys and sells coins and collectibles for numismatic enthusiasts. Operating by appointment only, this dedicated dealer offers expert knowledge in precious metals, rare coins, and numismatic investments. Whether you're looking to buy, sell, or appraise coins, Greencastle Coins provides personalized service to collectors and investors in the local community.
Greencastle Coins is a specialized coin dealer in Greencastle, IN that buys and sells coins and collectibles for numismatic enthusiasts. Operating by appointment only, this dedicated dealer offers expert knowledge in precious metals, rare coins, and numismatic investments. Whether you're looking to buy, sell, or appraise coins, Greencastle Coins provides personalized service to collectors and investors in the local community.
Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.
0
They werevery nice people.— Mike, Apr 2025
Great place has a great variety and great staff would recommend to anyone interested in buying or selling coins— Wesley Vittatoe, May 2025
4 star review— Mark, Oct 2025
I’ve been following their FB page for quite a while, but hadn’t made it in until today...and I’m so glad that I finally did! I was pleasantly surprised by their large selection of coins, rounds, commemoratives, bars, sets, holders, books, etc. - all at quite reasonable prices. Owner is knowledgeable and very nice. No matter what you’re looking for, stop by and take a look around. I went in to buy a couple small things, and ended up with something that I had almost completely given up on looking for!— Randall Spannuth, Sep 2020
Trash experience, another reviewer (Harley burkhart) is correct, lousy customer experience, felt like I was making them do chores to help me. Seemed like they were trying to tell me a obviously bubbled bicentennial was ran over by a vehicle and worthless just to get it dirt cheap. Would not doubt it if they lied to most of they're customers to scam them into buying a coin for a fraction of its value.— Brandon Weaver, Jan 2024
Todd is a great guy. Very knowledgeable and super friendly. Always willing to chat. If he can't help you he will put you in contact with the right people. Would recommend to everyone.— Nicole Rivers, Nov 2022
It says they are there to answer questions so I called to ask one and before I finished my question he answered with an annoyed tone. He answered honestly maybe but who wants to go to the store after being treated like that over a phone call and one question.— Maggie, May 2025
Great service personally know the owner I have never had a problem with anything at that store .— Crystal Cassetty, May 2025
You must be logged in to leave a review.
Log In to Review
