🏪

Collectors Exchange

Name: Collectors Exchange
Address: North Oakwood Avenue, Muncie, IN, 47304, US
Telephone: +1 (765) 729-5507
Rating: 4.4

ID: 4826Store129 mi from youMuncie, IN 47304 +1 (765) 729-5507

With nearly 20 years of experience, Collectors Exchange is one of Indiana's most trusted coin dealers and buyers of collectibles, offering expert appraisals and competitive offers for collections of any size. Located in the Williamsburg Center on North Oakwood Ave in Muncie, this buying hub specializes in purchasing coins, sports cards, and vintage collectibles with extensive knowledge of current market values. Open Monday through Saturday from 10 am to 5 pm, appointments…

4.4(33 reviews)

Share this Dealer

About Collectors Exchange

Active ListingLast verified: February 27, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

Official Source →Report a correction

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review

4.4

★★★★½

8 reviews · 4.4 (25 on Google)

5★

4★

3★

2★

1★

Rob CumminsGoogle★☆☆☆☆Jul 2024

No such business at that address. Number goes to voice mail. No return calls. Be aware!!

— Rob Cummins, Jul 2024

Kim RunyonGoogle★★★★★Sep 2024

Friendly fast service very reasonable fair pricing great place for ur sports collectors in the family ALIL of EVERYTHING ILL GO BACK!! N U SHOULD TOO!!!!! 💯

— Kim Runyon, Sep 2024

Duane PruettGoogle★★★★☆Nov 2024

Haircut

— Duane Pruett, Nov 2024

Matthew FriendGoogle★★★★★Jan 2022

Owner is extremely knowledgeable and helpful when it comes to sports cards. He has helped me multiple times when I was looking for a specific card(s) for my personal collection. Highly recommended.

— Matthew Friend, Jan 2022

View on Google

Jeremy MooreGoogle★★★★★Jan 2022

Dustin at Collectors Exchange is great to work with. Honest, knowledgeable, friendly and attentive to all detail. Would highly recommend going with them if you are looking to sell any type of collection.

— Jeremy Moore, Jan 2022

View on Google

Charles WoolumsGoogle★★★★★Dec 2025

Great customer service and lots of quality merchandise

— Charles Woolums, Dec 2025

View on Google

Eulaine DelgadoGoogle★★★★★Jan 2022

Dustin is a great collector to deal with. He explains everything fully, has been buying and selling for many years and knows his market. I found him personable, articulate, honest, reliable, quick to respond and easy to find. I highly recommend him. I sold to him twice and will meet him one more time when my items are organized to sell. I also plan to donate some collectables which may not be too marketable and hope he can find a good home for them.

— Eulaine Delgado, Jan 2022

View on Google