Castle Pawn is a trusted coin dealer in New Castle, IN offering a comprehensive selection of coins and numismatic collectibles for both seasoned collectors and newcomers. The shop specializes in buying and selling coins, including rare and vintage pieces, as well as precious metals at competitive prices. Whether you're looking to expand your collection or sell coins you no longer need, Castle Pawn provides expert knowledge and fair valuations in New Castle.
Castle Pawn is a trusted coin dealer in New Castle, IN offering a comprehensive selection of coins and numismatic collectibles for both seasoned collectors and newcomers. The shop specializes in buying and selling coins, including rare and vintage pieces, as well as precious metals at competitive prices. Whether you're looking to expand your collection or sell coins you no longer need, Castle Pawn provides expert knowledge and fair valuations in New Castle.
Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.
0
2 star review— Bria, Oct 2025
1 star review— Zach Bookout, Dec 2025
Do not go to this place he is a joke— Austen Floyd, Dec 2025
Terrible place... Have tried to do business with them multiple times and it never works out. Brought a tablet in and was told if it's not an iPad we normally don't take it. Next time I go there the same exact tablet is sitting on display. Some pawn shops are decent but this one is a complete joke.— Jarrod Daffron, Oct 2024
One of the rudest people I’ve ever met, I asked the price for something behind the case and he said “whatever it’s marked as” I could not read the tag and asked what the price was and you would have thought I killed him. It was such an inconvenience for him to tell me the price of a hammer behind the counter. I was shopping for some mechanics tools for my tool set. Never seen a pawnshop that says “prices are firm, we don’t need your business” this is what’s up on their wall btw— Tech Nstuff, Jun 2024
The other reviews aren't exaggerated. Went in today, to buy not one but TWO guitars from him. I asked him if we could plug one in and his face turned red, he got up hastily as if I was bothering him, then asked me "Ya gonna buy?!" In a very rude way. So I said "No, not now" and left after explaining to him how ignorant his behavior was. Avoid this place.— Griff Tanski, Jan 2025
Brought a 450 $ Jackson brand new and he offered me 25 $ this place is a joke— Blaine Kwisz, Dec 2025
Find somewhere else to get a Uhaul. Got gas at the closest gas station just down the road and filled it up til the pump clicked off on its own. They still charged us the 40 dollar fee for them to put gas in it. Absolute scam to put an easy 40 bucks in his own pocket.— MageXamnin, Sep 2025
You must be logged in to leave a review.
Log In to Review
