This Carmel, IN coin dealer specializes in buying and selling coins and numismatic collectibles for both seasoned collectors and newcomers. Amanda's Exchange offers a wide selection of rare coins, precious metals, and numismatic items backed by expert knowledge and fair pricing. Visit this trusted coin dealer in Carmel to buy, sell, or trade your coins and precious metal investments.
This Carmel, IN coin dealer specializes in buying and selling coins and numismatic collectibles for both seasoned collectors and newcomers. Amanda's Exchange offers a wide selection of rare coins, precious metals, and numismatic items backed by expert knowledge and fair pricing. Visit this trusted coin dealer in Carmel to buy, sell, or trade your coins and precious metal investments.
Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.
0
4 star review— Kat Toebes, Dec 2025
One of the best second-hand stores in the greater Indianapolis area.— Crystal Grave, Dec 2025
This place is awesome! So much cool stuff. All high end. Staff are very knowledgeable about each piece. We go at least once a week to see what's new. Continues to have a wide selection with great prices.— Zainul Hasanali, Dec 2025
This is Kelly, Eric's wife. I come into your store often as I love the quality, items and pricing. So great! If only the staff would be friendly. I feel like they are put out by my being there. It's too bad really.— Eric kichler, Nov 2025
A nice assortment of consigned goods. Women's, juniors, and children's apparel, purses, jewelry, furnishings, and several home accents decorations are all available in abundance at this boutique. Many brands you want at fantastic pricing. There is a small area of men's clothes. Visit their online store as well.— Lonnie Perry, Mar 2025
My first experience at Amanda’s Exchange and it was great! I love how organized everything is. All clothes and shoes are sorted based on either size, brand, or category. Barb was absolutely wonderful. Very sweet and helpful. Be sure to bring your own bag!— Hal, Nov 2025
So many cute clothes here and love the way it is organized by outfit type but also by brand. Changing room lighting isn't great but glad there are plenty so you don't have to wait much and you can bring up to 10 items, so it's pretty efficient in that way! They do not have bags anymore but you can purchase or bring your own.— Evalyn LaCoursiere, Feb 2026
You must be logged in to leave a review.
Log In to Review