Located in Pocatello, ID, this coin dealer specializes in buying and selling coins and numismatic collectibles for both seasoned collectors and beginners. Xtreme Collectibles offers expert knowledge in precious metals and rare coins, providing fair valuations and competitive pricing on quality inventory. Whether you're looking to expand your collection or sell coins, this Pocatello-based dealer is your trusted source for numismatics and bullion.
Located in Pocatello, ID, this coin dealer specializes in buying and selling coins and numismatic collectibles for both seasoned collectors and beginners. Xtreme Collectibles offers expert knowledge in precious metals and rare coins, providing fair valuations and competitive pricing on quality inventory. Whether you're looking to expand your collection or sell coins, this Pocatello-based dealer is your trusted source for numismatics and bullion.
Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.
0
5 star review— Dominic Hammack, Jan 2026
This place is awesome! I collect an open Pokémon cards with my son and they have fair pricing atmosphere and good staff!— frank green, Jan 2026
Went there a few days ago and they offered terrible prices for the cards I was selling. Told me they use price charting and ebay for prices and then I told them the prices. They still offered me very low. They buy your cards for cheap and sell them for more at ridiculous prices. I saw that they have card that there selling for $900 or $1000 and I checked the market price for that card. The card was going for $500-$550 market price. I recommend not to sell and buy cards at this store.— Owen Smith, Feb 2026
5 star review— Flix13, Feb 2026
Just went there today and they are a good store quiet and cozy— thecowboyof gods, Feb 2026
Friendly and always happy to help with learning about my card collection always has card to look throw— nuhall tuhall, Nov 2025
My son wanted to go check out what baseball card selection looked like. He’s been opening boxes and missing a bit so was dying for some signed cards. Got really good pricing on a few signed cards for the boy and he treated him really well and was patient with him which I really appreciated.— Jake dyer, Dec 2025
Hidden gem in Pocatello!!! Awesome prices and selection. Bought two comics from them and they were super easy to deal with, honest, and great to talk to. I will definitely make the 50 minute drive to buy more stuff. As a major collector I was really excited to find a collectibles store so close.— Phillip Langston, Nov 2025
I always recommend this place to all my friends that collect cards! And all customers where I work that like TCG’s & other card collections. They have a very wide variety and my opinion the best prices. There is another card shop here in pocatello/chubbuck (I won’t say by name) that was trying to charge me $40 more than what the pack was worth and not to mention customer service was par. It was my first time buying a booster pack and they were a bit rude about it. But not these guys!!, I came over here and the exact same pack was a little cheaper, and not to mention they have the best customer service. Anytime I think I have a rare card or have any questions the manager knows exactly what he’s talking about! Not to mention they’re getting into magic the gathering so that’s a plus! Anyway check out this place. Love the energy, love the products, and I’ll always be a customer here 😎🙏— Ark, Oct 2025
My brothers and I went in to see if they had some cards and they had a really good selection of Magic and Pokemon cards! Pretty happy we found the place because Pocatello has been needing a good card shop for awhile! Definitely worth checking out and the people there were super chill and nice!— Gage Palmer, Dec 2025
You must be logged in to leave a review.
Log In to Review
